Impact of skin biopsy practices: A comprehensive nationwide study on skin cancer and melanoma biopsies

G. G. Nervil,T. Vestergaard,S. Klausen,M. G. Tolsgaard,N. K. Ternov,L. R. Hölmich
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jdv.20371
2024-10-13
Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology
Abstract:Skin biopsy decision‐making is challenging. From a comprehensive national pathology registry including all biopsies, we investigated benign to malignant ratios (BMR) and number needed to biopsy (NNB) for lesions that might clinically mimic melanoma, for all biopsies and biopsies clinically suspected of cancer or melanoma. From 4.5 million included biopsies we found that (1) clinical suspicion of cancer impacts the BMR for malignancy and drastically affects the NNB for melanoma. (2) The amount of skin biopsies increased by 39% from 2007 to 2021. (3) The public funded healthcare system in Denmark spends €6.5M on benign skin lesions suspected of being melanoma—with the vast majority of these expenses from the hospital sector of the healthcare system. We therefore conclude that (1) layered triage helps separate low‐risk from high‐risk biopsies to achieve world‐class NNB for melanoma and (2) it is crucial to include the clinical reason for biopsy in diagnostic accuracy studies focusing on NNB. Background Due to a multitude of factors, skin cancer incidence is increasing and challenges medical professionals in biopsy decision‐making. While skin cancer may have a profound impact on the patient and be costly for society, there is little knowledge about the number and cost of benign skin lesions biopsied as collateral damage. Objectives This study evaluates the number and costs of skin biopsies in Denmark over 15 years, focusing on benign and malignant skin lesions and melanomas across medical settings. It aims to determine the benign to malignant ratio (BMR) and number needed to biopsy (NNB) and estimate the direct cost of benign skin lesion biopsies in the Cancer Pathway from the perspective of a public healthcare system. Methods The study included 4,481,207 biopsy specimens from January 2007 to June 2022 from the Danish Pathology Data Bank, of which 151,988 from the Cancer Pathway were included in the primary analysis of BMR. The national reimbursement rates for biopsies were used, alongside histopathological examination costs extracted from several pathology departments, for a Monte‐Carlo simulation of a simple cost and sensitivity analysis. Results The number of biopsies increased by 39.1% from 2007 to 2021. Overall BMR for malignancy was 4.1:1, and NNB for melanoma was 31.8, but biopsies performed on clinical suspicion of malignancy or melanoma had a BMR and NNB of 1.5:1 and 2.8, respectively. The cost of benign skin biopsies performed on suspicion of cancer or melanoma in 2021 was €6.6M, predominantly in hospitals. Conclusion A healthcare system that employs filtering functions before biopsy of skin lesions can achieve some of the lowest BMR reported in the world, but with most benign skin lesion excisions due to suspicion of malignancy performed in the expensive hospital setting. Including clinical reason for biopsy in diagnostic accuracy studies using NNB is crucial.
dermatology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?