A Bayesian functional approach to test models of life course epidemiology over continuous time

Julien Bodelet,Cecilia Potente,Guillaume Blanc,Justin Chumbley,Hira Imeri,Scott Hofer,Kathleen Mullan Harris,Graciela Muniz-Terrera,Michael Shanahan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyad190
IF: 9.685
2024-01-10
International Journal of Epidemiology
Abstract:Abstract Background Life course epidemiology examines associations between repeated measures of risk and health outcomes across different phases of life. Empirical research, however, is often based on discrete-time models that assume that sporadic measurement occasions fully capture underlying long-term continuous processes of risk. Methods We propose (i) the functional relevant life course model (fRLM), which treats repeated, discrete measures of risk as unobserved continuous processes, and (ii) a testing procedure to assign probabilities that the data correspond to conceptual models of life course epidemiology (critical period, sensitive period and accumulation models). The performance of the fRLM is evaluated with simulations, and the approach is illustrated with empirical applications relating body mass index (BMI) to mRNA-seq signatures of chronic kidney disease, inflammation and breast cancer. Results Simulations reveal that fRLM identifies the correct life course model with three to five repeated assessments of risk and 400 subjects. The empirical examples reveal that chronic kidney disease reflects a critical period process and inflammation and breast cancer likely reflect sensitive period mechanisms. Conclusions The proposed fRLM treats repeated measures of risk as continuous processes and, under realistic data scenarios, the method provides accurate probabilities that the data correspond to commonly studied models of life course epidemiology. fRLM is implemented with publicly-available software.
public, environmental & occupational health
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to more accurately assess the association between repeatedly measured risk factors and health outcomes in life - course epidemiology. Traditional methods are usually based on discrete - time models, assuming that a limited number of repeated measurements of risk at different life stages can fully capture the long - term continuous risk process. However, this method may not accurately reflect the real risk exposure situation, especially in cases involving continuous risk processes, such as physiological attacks in addictive behaviors (such as tobacco or alcohol consumption) that are ongoing. For this reason, the author proposes a new method - the Functional - related Life - Course Model (fRLM), which regards repeated discrete risk measurements as unobserved continuous processes and links these risks to health outcomes through weighted integration. Specifically, fRLM assumes that health outcomes depend on the weighted integral of risk exposure: \[ y_i=\alpha+\delta\int_{a}^{b}X_i(t)x(t)dt + C_0+\epsilon_i\] where \(X_i(t)\) is a random function observed at a finite number of discrete time points, \(x(t)\) is a positive continuous weight function, and \(t\) represents the exact age. This model allows for a different number of measurements for each subject and is suitable for panel studies starting from age - heterogeneous groups. Through this method, fRLM aims to overcome the limitations of existing discrete - time models and provide a more accurate method to test cumulative models, critical - period models, and sensitive - period models in life - course epidemiology. The paper also proposes a Sequential Partitioning Test (SPT) to determine which life - course model best describes the data. Overall, the goal of this paper is to develop a new statistical method to better understand and interpret the impact of risk factors on health in the life course.