Abstract:This paper examines the Multistakeholder initiative (MSI) "German Initiative on Sustainable Cocoa (GISCO)". MSIs represent arenas in which heterogeneous actors from governments, businesses and civil society come together to achieve sustainability goals that they cannot achieve otherwise. The self-defined goals of GISCO are first, to improve the living conditions of cocoa farmers and their families; second, to conserve and protect natural resources and biodiversity; and third, to increase the share of sustainably produced cocoa. Although all stakeholder groups share these goals, they have different agendas and conflicting interests. Despite numerous case studies, no theoretical basis has been established on the functioning and success of negotiations in MSIs. Therefore, the question arises as to how the governance of an MSI can be captured empirically to explain (un)achieved outcomes of the collaboration. The contribution of this paper is the development of a theoretical framework and its application to the case study. Minutes of 84 meetings and 18 qualitative expert interviews were analyzed by social network analysis and qualitative content analysis using MaxQDA to identify (a) influential actors, (b) collaboration structures and (c) processes as well as (d) topics discussed to explain (not) achieved outcomes regarding the self-defined goals. The results provide detailed insight into the governance of an MSI. The MSI helps members to extend their individual networks and to learn from each other, but quickly reaches its limits in achieving the self-imposed common goals. One reason for this is the lack of representation of actors from the Global South, despite addressing environmental and living conditions there in two out of the three GISCO goals. Furthermore, it is shown that the structures and processes of decision-making within the MSI are designed in such a way that a lack of hierarchical directives, sanctions and other decision-making mechanisms makes negotiation-based compromises difficult. Consequently, the power of each stakeholder group to use their veto right to delay or prevent the changes required to achieve common goals cannot be overcome.

Multi-stakeholder governance: a necessity and a challenge for global governance in the twenty-first century

Multi-stakeholder internet governance: successes and opportunities

The crucial and contested global public good: principles and goals in global internet governance

Participation, Coordination, Agreement...Action? Evaluating the Multistakeholder Model in Internet Governance

Improving the governance of information technology: Insights from the history of Internet governance

The Internet: New principles of political right, new social contract

Internet Governance: System Imbalances and Ways to Resolve Them

Globalization and Governance in Cyberspace: Mapping the Processes of Emergent Regime Formation in Global Information and Communications Policy

Stakeholder Management: a Business Philosophy in the Era of New Economy

Global digital governance: paradigm shift and an analytical framework

Meeting Cyber Age Needs for Governance in a Changing Global Order

Governance as a complex, networked, democratic, satisfiability problem

Multistakeholder Initiatives and Sustainability? A Governance Analysis using the German Initiative on Sustainable Cocoa (GISCO) as a Case Study

Governing Complex Systems

Meeting the Grand Challenges of Planetary Governance: is It Time for a Paradigm Shift?

Grand challenges of planetary governance in the 21st century

Digital technology-enabled governance for sustainability in global value chains: a framework and future research agenda

Decentralized Network Governance: Blockchain Technology and the Future of Regulation

Cross‐scale, cross‐level and multi‐actor governance of transformations toward the Sustainable Development Goals: A review of common challenges and solutions

DNS, Cyber Sovereignty, and Global Internet Governance Historical Reflections and Contemporary Implications

Introduction: New Perspectives on Governahnce for Sustainable Development