An Experience Report on Assessing Software Engineer’s Outputs in Practice

Juzheng Zhang,He Zhang,Lanxin Yang,Yue Li,Liming Dong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ICSSP59042.2023.00012

2023-05-01

Abstract:The success of a software organization relies heavily on the quality of its products and services, which in turn are influenced by the knowledge, capability, and experience of the software engineers involved in development processes. It is popular to apply quantitative assessments of software engineers for quality assurance. However, the extent to which it benefits software organizations and how it can be effectively implemented in industrial settings remains unclear. One global Information and Communications Technology (ICT) enterprise has implemented a quantitative assessment practice of software engineer’s outputs to improve its engineering capability and product and service quality. To investigate the benefits and experiences of adopting this practice in industrial settings, we conducted an empirical study using a mixed-method approach (i.e., archive analysis, interviews, and surveys). The results indicate that this practice can benefit the ICT enterprise in terms of standardizing development processes, optimizing team structures, and offering suggestions for training and management, etc. Meanwhile, this paper reports on the best practices to tackle the challenges during the adoption of the practice in the ICT enterprise, e.g., customization for teams and synergy of quantitative and qualitative assessment. In addition, we discuss the implications and recommendations of institutionalizing quantitative engineer assessment in software organizations. For organizations intending to improve software quality from the human aspect, this study provides empirical references on how to implement quantitative engineer assessment meanwhile mitigate potential risks.

Computer Science