Abstract:It has long been recognized that avian mass loss during breeding could be adaptive, though many studies still commonly interpret mass loss as evidence of "stress" or a cost of reproduction. Here, we used a long‐term dataset from a breeding population of European starlings to investigate the ecological and/or life‐history contexts under which mass loss may be viewed as a "cost" or an adaptive strategy and, specifically, test whether mass loss during chick rearing represents a phenotypically plastic trait that varies predictably in relation to ecological context and individual quality. Overall, we found no support for the idea that mass loss reflects "reproductive stress" in our system and instead suggest that mass loss may represent an individually plastic trait that individuals use to "level the playing field" and individually optimize reproductive effort and fitness. It has long been recognized that mass loss during breeding could be adaptive (e.g., by ameliorating the costs of increased parental activity). However, many studies still commonly interpret mass loss as evidence of "stress" or a cost of reproduction (i.e., a negative effect of high workload during chick provisioning). Despite several studies reporting evidence in support of both hypotheses, the ecological and/or life‐history contexts under which mass loss may be viewed as a "cost" or an adaptive strategy are still unclear. Here, we used a long‐term dataset from a breeding population of European starlings (Sturnus vulgaris) to investigate natural annual and individual variation in body mass and mass loss and to test whether mass loss during chick rearing represents a phenotypically plastic trait that varies predictably in relation to ecological context and individual quality. While there was significant annual variation in incubation mass, chick‐rearing mass, and mass change, there were no systematic relationships between mass loss and current breeding success or future fecundity and survival. In addition, we found no evidence of intra‐annual repeatability of mass loss between first and second broods ( = .00) but moderate interannual repeatability of mass loss (R = .61) during first broods, suggesting differences in mass loss under different selective pressures. However, we found no covariation between residual intra‐individual variation in mass loss for first broods and other reproductive or life‐history traits. We therefore found no support for the idea that mass loss reflects "reproductive stress" in our system: there were no negative relationships between mass loss and either current or future reproduction and survival (local return rate). Our results are consistent with mass loss being an individually plastic trait, with individuals using mass loss to "level the playing field" and individually optimize reproductive effort and fitness within their specific ecological context and relative to their individual quality for a given breeding attempt.

Age and reproductive strategies in European Starlings (Sturnus vulgaris)

Timing of egg-laying in relation to a female’s social environment in European starlings

Removal of older males increases extra-pair siring success of yearling males

Offspring sex ratio variation in relation to brood size and mortality in a promiscuous species: the Aquatic Warbler Acrocephalus paludicola

Mating systems in birds: a review of molecular studies

After second year male European Starlings (Sturnus vulgaris) do not signal age through repertoire size or song bout length over a 1‐year period

Reproductive Skew in an Avian Cooperative Breeder: an Empirical Test for Theoretical Models

Population Sex Ratio Shift from Fledging to Recruitment: Consequences for Demography in A Philopatric Seabird

Disentangling the age-dependent causal pathways affecting multiple paternity in house sparrows

Inequality among offspring, correlates of recruitment and lifetime reproductive success in a long-lived raptor

Differences in the ages, sexes and physical condition of Starlings Sturnus vulgaris at the centre and periphery of roosts

The contribution of extra-pair paternity to the variation in lifetime and age-specific male reproductive success in a socially monogamous species

Low level of extra-pair paternity in an urban population of blackbirds

Phenotypic plasticity in mass loss during chick rearing in the European starling (Sturnus vulgaris)

Stay or go? Changing breeding conditions affect sexual difference in colony attendance strategies of Atlantic puffins Fratercula arctica

Combined high rates of alternative breeding strategies unexpectedly found among populations of a solitary nesting raptor

Availability of mates and food influence the plasticity in strategies mediating life‐history tradeoffs in an insect

Temporal and spatial variation in reproductive benefits in a partial migrant

Breeding behavior of sympatric silky starlings and white-cheeked starlings

Extra‐pair Paternity in Relation to Breeding Synchrony in Ground Tits: an Individual‐based Approach

Influence of Age and Time on Reproductive Performance of Female Lesser Scaup