Cognitive, Emotional, and Daily Functioning Domains Involved in Decision-Making among Patients with Mild Cognitive Impairment: A Systematic Review

Federica Alfeo,Tiziana Lanciano,Chiara Abbatantuono,Giorgia Gintili,Maria Fara De Caro,Antonietta Curci,Paolo Taurisano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/brainsci14030278

IF: 3.333

2024-03-15

Brain Sciences

Abstract:Mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is a transitional or prodromal stage of dementia in which autonomies are largely preserved (autonomies are not particularly affected). However, this condition may entail a depletion of decision-making (DM) abilities likely due to a gradual deterioration of the prefrontal cortex and subcortical brain areas underlying cognitive–emotional processing. Given the clinical implications of a decline in self-determination observed in some MCI sufferers, the present systematic review was aimed at investigating the literature addressing DM processes in patients with MCI, consistent with PRISMA guidelines. The six online databases inquired yielded 1689 research articles that were screened and then assessed based on eligibility and quality criteria. As a result, 41 studies were included and classified following the PICOS framework. Overall, patients with MCI who underwent neuropsychological assessment were found to be slightly or moderately impaired in DM abilities related to financial management, medical adherence, specific cognitive performances, risky conditions, and especially uncertain life circumstances. Comparative cross-sectional studies indicated not only mid-stage cognitive functioning in MCI but also borderline or deficit DM patterns evaluated through different tasks and procedures. Further research addressing MCI profiles suggested an association between explicit memory, executive functions, and DM performance. These findings highlight the diversity of MCI manifestations, in addition to the critical importance of DM features and correlates in patients' daily functioning. Due to a lack of consensus on both MCI and DM, this review paper sought to shed light on assessment and intervention strategies accounting for the interplay between emotion, motivation, and learning to foster DM in cognitively impaired individuals.

neurosciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the decision-making abilities of patients with Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI). Specifically, the authors use a systematic review approach to analyze studies related to decision-making in MCI patients in terms of cognition, emotion, and daily life functions. The main objectives include:

1. **Identifying and evaluating** existing literature on the decision-making abilities of MCI patients, particularly in financial management, medical compliance, specific cognitive performance, risk situations, and uncertain life situations.

2. **Comparing findings** from different studies to determine the characteristics of decision-making patterns in MCI patients and their differences from healthy control groups.

3. **Exploring the relationship** between decision-making abilities and other cognitive functions (such as memory, executive function, etc.) in MCI patients.

4. **Assessing the importance and impact** of decision-making abilities on the daily functions of MCI patients, especially in the process of self-determination.

By screening 1,689 research articles from six databases and based on preset inclusion criteria, 41 articles were ultimately selected for detailed analysis. These studies covered various types of decision-making abilities, including but not limited to financial management, medical decision-making, and risk decision-making. The results indicate that MCI patients generally perform poorly in these decision-making areas, especially in financial management and medical compliance. Additionally, there is a close relationship between decision-making abilities and cognitive functions such as memory and executive function. These findings highlight the importance of understanding the decision-making characteristics of MCI patients and their impact on daily life functions, providing guidance for clinical monitoring and support.