Land and sea transport options for the installation of green artificial reefs (GARs) in shallow waters: a Galician case study

Juan José Cartelle Barros,Alicia Munín-Doce,Laura Castro-Santos,Javier Lamas,Luis Carral
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-53183-0
IF: 4.6
2024-02-02
Scientific Reports
Abstract:The aim of the present paper is to propose a new methodology for the production and installation of green artificial reefs (GARs) in shallow waters, with special attention to the transport stages. The process includes both onshore (manufacturing, road transport and unload at port) and offshore (load at port, sea transport, positioning, and deployment tasks) stages. Two different types of truck were analysed for the road transport. Furthermore, three different options were considered for sea transport: a workboat powered by liquefied natural gas, a barge using diesel (0.1% sulphur) as fuel, and an electric specific design barge. A simulation tool called AGARDO (Automatic Green Artificial Reef Deploy Optimisation) was developed for such a purpose. An estuary located in Galicia (North-West of Spain), where 180 GAR units must be installed, has been considered as case study. AGARDO was used to obtain results concerning process total time, equivalent CO 2 emissions and costs for different scenarios. Consequently, the use of the proposed methodology allows the decision-maker to select the best option in terms of costs, emissions and time. AGARDO can be easily adapted to other case studies, with different onshore and offshore options.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to address methodological issues in the production, transportation, and installation processes of Green Artificial Reefs (GARs) in shallow waters. Specifically, the paper focuses on the land and sea transportation stages throughout the entire process and proposes a simulation tool named AGARDO (Automated Green Artificial Reef Deployment Optimization). Through this tool, researchers can analyze the total time, equivalent CO₂ emissions, and costs under different scenarios, thereby helping decision-makers choose the optimal solution. Additionally, the AGARDO tool is highly flexible and can adapt to different case studies and various land and sea options. The paper mainly addresses the following aspects: 1. **Production and Installation Process**: Proposes a new methodology to handle the entire process from production to installation of GARs. 2. **Comparison of Transportation Methods**: Provides a detailed analysis of different schemes for land transportation (two types of trucks) and sea transportation (three types of vessels). 3. **Simulation Tool Development**: Develops the AGARDO tool to simulate the entire process and evaluate the time, emissions, and costs of different schemes. 4. **Case Study Application**: Uses the Ares-Betanzos estuary in the Galicia region of Spain as a case study to explore the installation scheme of 180 GAR units. Through this methodology, the paper aims to provide decision-makers with a scientific basis to achieve the best balance between cost, environmental impact, and time efficiency when implementing artificial reef projects.