A chemical probe for the ATAD 2 bromodomain
P. Bamborough,C. Chung,E. Demont,Rebecca C. Furze,Andrew J. Bannister,K. Che,Hawa Diallo,Clement Douault,P. Grandi,T. Kouzarides,A. Michon,D. Mitchell,R. Prinjha,Christina E. Rau,S. Robson
Abstract:ATAD2 is a cancer-associated protein whose bromodomain has been described as among the least druggable of that target class. Starting from a potent lead, permeability and selectivity were improved through a dual approach: 1) using CF2 as a sulfone bio-isostere to exploit the unique properties of fluorine, and 2) using 1,3-interactions to control the conformation of a piperidine ring. This resulted in the first reported low-nanomolar, selective and cell permeable chemical probe for ATAD2. High expression levels of ATAD2 (ATPase family, AAA domain containing 2), also called ANCCA (AAA+ nuclear coregulator cancer-associated), correlate with poor outcomes in several cancers, and its knockdown modulates multiple tumor cell growth factors [1-3]. Efforts to target this protein have focused on competitive binding to the acetyl-lysine (KAc) site of its bromodomain, but the role of the bromodomain in the biology of ATAD2 is unclear. We have developed chemical tools to try to understand this, and recently reported the discovery of quinolinones and naphthyridones such as 1-3 and 5-7 that bind to the KAc site of ATAD2 [4,5]. The profound biological effects associated with BET inhibition complicate interpretation of phenotypes observed with unselective inhibitors of other bromodomains [6]. While potent against ATAD2, naphthyridone 5 had only modest selectivity over the BETs, represented in Table 1 by the first bromodomain of BRD4 (BRD4 BD1). We recently reported selectivity improvements from occupying an electrostatically positive site near the KAc pocket, the RVF shelf, with negative polarity (compare 5 to 6 to see the effect of introducing cyclic sulfones at the C3’ position of the piperidine ring with (R,R) stereochemistry) [5]. An X-ray structure of ATAD2 bound to 3 showed that its sulfone oxygen atoms displace a weakly-bound water molecule and accept two hydrogen bonds from the guanidinium group of Arg1077 (Figure 1a). The WPF shelf of the BET bromodomains (the analogous subsite to the ATAD2 RVF shelf) contains lipophilic amino acids Trp81 and Met149 in place of ATAD2 residues Arg1007 and Arg1077, so is less tolerant of the sulfone group’s polarity. Compounds with hydrophobic C3’substituents such as the cyclohexylmethylenes 2 and 5 are more potent against the BETs, which is consistent with the crystal structure of 2 bound to BRD4 BD1, where the C3’cyclohexyl ring rests on the WPF shelf (Figure 1b). Unfortunately, while the sulfone C3’ group improved selectivity it also impacted passive permeability, raising doubts over the suitability of 6 and 7 as tool compounds for chromatin-bound ATAD2. Here, we describe the conclusion of our optimization of the series to overcome this. Table 1. Micromolar lead to nanomolar ATAD2 inhibitors. For statistics see Table S1a, Supporting Information. Alternative C3’ functional groups of intermediate polarity had been found inferior to the sulfone in potency or selectivity [5]. We therefore considered the possibilities offered by fluorine substitution. The effect of fluorine on features of organic molecules such as conformation, pKa, permeability and metabolism has recently been reviewed [7]. Fluorine combines unique properties of polarity, lipophilicity and low polarisability [8-10]. Regarding noncovalent interactions, the ability of organofluorine to participate in hydrogen bonds has been debated [10-15]. While the lone pairs of organic fluorine seem too tightly held to hydrogen-bond, strong charge-dipole interactions can be formed with cations [15]. The bi-lobal negative charge patches characteristic of the molecular surface of the SO2 group of 3 are well oriented to interact with the ATAD2 RVF shelf residue Arg1077 (Figure 1a). The CF2 group possesses geometrically similar electronegative patches (Figure S1, Supporting Information) and should be compatible with polar interactions with Arg1077. Indeed, the guanidinium group of arginine has been described as highly fluorophilic [14]. We reasoned that CF2 may provide an isosteric replacement for SO2, that its large dipole moment relative to CH2 (2.57 D in 1,1-difluorocyclohexane [16]) might disfavour interaction with the hydrophobic BRD4 BD1 WPF shelf, and that the expected increase in lipophilicity should have a positive effect on permeability. 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ATAD2 TR-FRET pIC50 5.6 7.2 6.9 6.7 6.9 6.5 7.4 7.1 ATAD2 Bromosphere pIC50 5.4 7.4 7.3 6.5 7.5 7.0 7.2 7.1 BRD4 BD1 TR-FRET pIC50 5.4 5.4 5.0 5.8 4.8 4.1 5.2 5.1 TR-FRET selectivity (logs) 0.2 1.8 1.9 0.9 2.1 2.4 2.2 2.0 Chrom logD (pH 7.4) 3.3 2.1 0.4 4.0 1.6 2.3 3.0 4.1 Polar Surface Area (Å2) 79 113 152 92 126 117 92 83 Artificial membrane permeability (nM/s, pH 7.4) 130 < 3 < 3 138 < 3 < 10 86 395