Abstract:Soil compaction caused by random traffic or repetitive tillage has been shown to reduce water use efficiency, and thus crop yield due to reduced porosity, decreased water infiltration and availability of nutrients. Conservation tillage coupled with subsoiling in northern China is widely believed to reduce soil compaction, which was created after many years of no-till. However, limited research has been conducted on the most effective time interval for subsoiling, under conservation tillage. Data from conservation tillage demonstration sites operating for 10 years in northern China were used to conduct a comparative study of subsoiling interval under conservation tillage. Three modes of traditional tillage, subsoiling with soil cover and no-till with soil cover were compared using 10 years of soil bulk density, water content, yield and water use efficiency data. Cost benefit analysis was conducted on subsoiling time interval under conservation tillage. Yield and power consumption were assessed by based on the use of a single pass combine subsoiler and planter. Annual subsoiling was effective in reducing bulk density by only 4.9% compared with no-till treatments on the silty loam soils of the Loess plateau, but provided no extra benefit in terms of soil water loss, yield increase or water utilization. With the exception of bulk density, no-till and subsoiling with cover were vastly superior in increasing water use (+10.5%) efficiency and yield (+12.9%) compared to traditional tillage methods. Four years of no-till followed by one subsoiling reduced mechanical inputs by 62%, providing an economic benefit of 49% for maize and 209% for wheat production compared to traditional tillage. Annual subsoiling reduced inputs by 25% with an increased economic benefit of 23% for maize and 135% for wheat production. Yield and power consumption was improved by 5% and 20%, respectively, by combining subsoiling with the planting operation in one pass compared with multipass operations of subsoiling and planting. A key conclusion from this is that annual subsoiling in dryland areas of northern China is uneconomical and unwarranted. Four years of no-till operations followed by 1 year subsoiling provided some relief from accumulated soil compaction. However, minimum soil disturbance and maximum soil cover are key elements of no-till for saving water and improving yields. Improved yields and reduced farm power consumption could provide a significant base on which to promote combined planter and subsoiling operations throughout northern China. Further research is required to develop a better understanding of the linkages between conservation tillage, soil quality and yield, aimed at designing most appropriate conservation tillage schemes.

Physical, chemical and biological subsoiling for sustainable agriculture

Combining Rotary and Deep Tillage Increases Crop Yields by Improving the Soil Physical Structure and Accumulating Organic Carbon of Subsoil

Impact of long‐term sub‐soiling tillage on soil porosity and soil physical properties in the soil profile

Current Knowledge and Future Directions for Improving Subsoiling Quality and Reducing Energy Consumption in Conservation Fields

Subsoiling Impact on Soil Physical Structure, Root Activity, Photosynthetic Characteristics, and Water Use Efficiency in Maize

Quantifying the impact of induced topsoil and historical subsoil compaction as well as the persistence of subsoiling

Sub-soiling improves productivity and economic returns of cotton-wheat cropping system

Effects of Varied Tillage Practices on Soil Quality in the Experimental Field of Red-Soil Sloping Farmland in Southern China

Soil compaction due to agricultural machinery impact: A systematic review

Comprehensive assessment of paddy soil quality under land consolidation: a novel perspective of microbiology.

Long-Term Impact of Farming Practices on Soil Organic Carbon and Nitrogen Pools and Microbial Biomass and Activity

The adoption of annual subsoiling as conservation tillage in dryland maize and wheat cultivation in northern China

Significant soil degradation is associated with intensive vegetable cropping in a subtropical area: a case study in southwestern China

Subsurface Clay Soil Application Improved Aggregate Stability, Nitrogen Availability, and Organic Carbon Preservation in Degraded Ultisols with Cover Crop Mixtures

Residue incorporation enhances the effect of subsoiling on soil structure and increases SOC accumulation

Effects of Subsoiling on Soil Moisture Under No-Tillage for Two Years

The tillage effect on the change of soil structure

Impact of Combining Long-Term Subsoiling and Organic Fertilizer on Soil Microbial Biomass Carbon and Nitrogen, Soil Enzyme Activity, and Water Use of Winter Wheat

Effect of Mild Organic Substitution on Soil Quality and Microbial Community

Long-term tillage and cropping systems affect soil organic carbon components and mineralization in aggregates in semiarid regions