Transfer processes of potential toxic elements (PTE) between rock-soil systems and soil risk evaluation in the Baoshan area, Yunnan Province, Southwest China

Li Zhang,Jennifer McKinley,Mark Cooper,Wei Han,Fei Liu,Yuntao Song,Min Peng,Xiujin Liu,Wei Yang,Hangxin Cheng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apgeochem.2020.104712
IF: 3.4
2020-10-01
Applied Geochemistry
Abstract:<p>Geochemical fluxes in rock-soil systems are important processes in the evaluation of soil environmental risk, especially where the geological background (parent materials) are enriched in potential toxic elements (PTE). In the Baoshan area, the presence of mineral resources along with carbonate and basalt parent materials often leads to PTE being elevated in soils. In this study, we compared rock and soil geochemical compositions by collecting rock samples from the host formations and ore samples from two mineral deposits (Cu-Pb-Zn and Fe-Cu-Pb-Zn) and their overlying soils. This research demonstrates enrichment of PTE (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, Ni, Pb and Zn) in soils relative to their parent materials. The enrichment in soils may be due to the removal of mobile elements (e.g., Ca, Na, Mg, and Sr), and coprecipitation (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, Ni, Pb and Zn) and/or adsorption by Fe-oxy-hydroxides (Cr and Ni) under the influence of high pH values during soil formation. The results point to a parent lithological origin and natural enrichment of PTE in Baoshan soils. However, anthropogenic contamination of soils near mining areas is also possible. Soils forming from carbonate rocks, basalts, and especially from mineralized formations have higher PTE concentrations, and in places, levels can exceed the risk screening values for soil contamination of agricultural land of China. Where the latter is the case, it is suggested that ecological monitoring be implemented in the study area. The conventional use of the geo-accumulation index (I<sub>geo</sub>) and enrichment factor (EF) methods is challenged in this research and found to underestimate the PTE contamination. A compositional data analysis approach (using clr biplots) is presented which shows that comparison with regional-scale background datasets is essential to provide a more informative approach to evaluate the risk of soil contamination, especially in regions with elevated levels of PTE in parent materials.</p>
geochemistry & geophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the following key issues: 1. **Migration process of Potentially Toxic Elements (PTE) in the rock-soil system**: The study aims to reveal the migration process of potentially toxic elements from rocks to soil in different geological structures, particularly the enrichment of these elements in the soil. 2. **Soil environmental risk assessment**: By analyzing the migration and enrichment of potentially toxic elements under different geological backgrounds, the study evaluates the potential risks of these elements to the soil environment, especially in agricultural land. 3. **Improvement of assessment methods**: Traditional methods such as the Geological Accumulation Index (Igeo) and Enrichment Factor (EF) may underestimate the pollution levels of PTE in some cases. The study proposes the use of Compositional Data Analysis (CoDA) methods to more accurately assess the risk of soil pollution. Specifically, the study collected rock, ore, and overlying soil samples from the Baoshan area in Yunnan Province, analyzed the chemical composition of these samples, and explored the following points: - **Concentration differences of PTE in rocks and soil**: The study compared the concentrations of PTE in rocks and soil in different geological structures, revealing the enrichment of PTE in the soil. - **Mechanisms of PTE migration and enrichment**: The study analyzed the migration process of PTE from rocks to soil, exploring the co-precipitation and adsorption effects of Fe-hydroxides on PTE under high pH conditions. - **Ecological risk prediction**: Based on the concentration of PTE, the study assessed the ecological risk of the soil and proposed recommendations for ecological monitoring in high-risk areas. In summary, the study aims to provide a scientific basis for soil environmental risk assessment through detailed chemical analysis and statistical methods, by deeply understanding the migration and enrichment mechanisms of PTE in the rock-soil system.