Field Testing of Gamma-Spectroscopy Method for Soil Water Content Estimation in an Agricultural Field

Sophia M Becker,Trenton E Franz,Tanessa C Morris,Bailey Mullins,Sophia M. Becker,Trenton E. Franz,Tanessa C. Morris
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/s24072223
IF: 3.9
2024-03-31
Sensors
Abstract:Gamma-ray spectroscopy (GRS) enables continuous estimation of soil water content (SWC) at the subfield scale with a noninvasive sensor. Hydrological applications, including hyper-resolution land surface models and precision agricultural decision making, could benefit greatly from such SWC information, but a gap exists between established theory and accurate estimation of SWC from GRS in the field. In response, we conducted a robust three-year field validation study at a well-instrumented agricultural site in Nebraska, United States. The study involved 27 gravimetric water content sampling campaigns in maize and soybean and 40K specific activity (Bq kg−1) measurements from a stationary GRS sensor. Our analysis showed that the current method for biomass water content correction is appropriate for our maize and soybean field but that the ratio of soil mass attenuation to water mass attenuation used in the theoretical equation must be adjusted to satisfactorily describe the field data. We propose a calibration equation with two free parameters: the theoretical 40K intensity in dry soil and a, which creates an "effective" mass attenuation ratio. Based on statistical analyses of our data set, we recommend calibrating the GRS sensor for SWC estimation using 10 profiles within the footprint and 5 calibration sampling campaigns to achieve a cross-validation root mean square error below 0.035 g g−1.
engineering, electrical & electronic,chemistry, analytical,instruments & instrumentation
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve This paper aims to address the following issues: 1. **The need for soil water content (SWC) monitoring in agricultural and hydrological applications**: - Soil water content (SWC) plays a crucial role in the hydrological cycle and energy balance, and is important for climate monitoring, weather forecasting, and watershed modeling. - There is currently a lack of methods that can accurately monitor SWC at the sub-field scale, particularly within the resolution range of tens of meters. 2. **Limitations of existing soil moisture sensors**: - Existing point sensors (such as time-domain reflectometers) have high accuracy but poor spatial representativeness; satellite remote sensing methods have too high a resolution to capture critical sub-field scale variations. - A method is needed that can reliably monitor SWC at the sub-field scale to fill the gap between existing methods. 3. **Theoretical validation of gamma-ray spectroscopy (GRS) for monitoring SWC**: - Gamma-ray spectroscopy (GRS) can achieve continuous, non-destructive monitoring of SWC, but there is a gap between theory and actual data in practical applications. - Further validation of the theoretical basis of the GRS method is needed, along with the proposal of improved calibration equations to make it more suitable for actual field conditions. 4. **Proposing a new calibration equation**: - A new calibration equation with 2 free parameters is proposed, namely the theoretical intensity of 40K in dry soil and the "effective" mass attenuation ratio. - Based on data analysis, it is recommended to use 10 profiles and 5 calibration sampling activities to achieve a cross-validation root mean square error of less than 0.035 g/g. Through these studies, the paper aims to provide a reliable solution for SWC monitoring at the sub-field scale, thereby supporting precision agriculture decision-making and hydrological applications.