Abstract:Purpose: OptiSafeTM (OS) is a shelf stable, nonanimal test for ocular irritation. A recent database search found that half of the OS false positive (FP) materials were associated with reactive oxygen chemistries but were not eye irritants in vivo (based on historical rabbit studies by other groups). We hypothesized that naturally occurring tear antioxidants protect the eye from reactive chemistries in vivo and that specific tear chemistries might help explain why some materials are FP for nonanimal tests but are reported as nonirritants in the live animal. To test this hypothesis, a prior study evaluated tear antioxidants and found that the tear antioxidant ascorbic acid, added at human physiological tear levels to the OS test, specifically reduced the measured values for these FPs but did not reduce the true-positive rate. Based on these findings, the OS test method was further optimized. The purpose of the current study was to comprehensively evaluate the performance of the further optimized test method for detection of ocular irritants. Materials and methods: The OS test measures chemically induced damage to macromolecules and relates these measured values to ocular irritancy. To improve the performance of OS, we made updates to the material to be tested physiochemical handling procedures, prediction model, and test method to include tear-level concentrations of ascorbic acid. We then retested the 78 chemicals from the prior OS-coded validation study in triplicate and compared the accuracy of the 'nonirritant versus irritant' prediction for the further optimized method with the prior results. Results: We report that for the detection of 'nonirritant' versus 'irritant' (GHS NC versus categories 2B/A and 1) test substances, the further optimized OS test with ascorbic acid compared with the original version has a FP rate that is reduced from 40.0 to 22.2%, the false-negative (FN) rate remains at 0.0%, and the accuracy improved from 80.3% to 89.2%. Conclusion: A comparison to OECD-adopted tests demonstrates that the further optimized OS test, like the original method, has a higher accuracy and lower FN rate for the detection of 'nonirritants' versus 'irritants' (GHS Category NC versus 2B/A and 1) than the other eye irritation tests (BCOP, EpiOcularTM Eye Irritation Test, ICE, Ocular Irritection®, and STE).

A microelectric cell sensing technique for in vitro assessment of ocular irritation

The Toxicity of Phenylephrine Hydrochloride on Cultured Rabbit Corneal Endothelial Cells

An evaluation of a cultured human corneal epithelial tissue model for the determination of the ocular irritation potential of pharmaceutical process materials

Impedance-based in vitro eye irritation testing enables the categorization of diluted chemicals

Evaluation of in vitro cornea models for quantifying destructive effects of chemicals

Cosmetics Europe compilation of historical serious eye damage/eye irritation in vivo data analysed by drivers of classification to support the selection of chemicals for development and evaluation of alternative methods/strategies: the Draize eye test Reference Database (DRD)

Further optimisation of a macromolecular ocular irritation test (OptiSafeTM)

Integrated high-throughput drug screening microfluidic system for comprehensive ocular toxicity assessment

Human keratinocyte cultures in an in vitro approach for the assessment of surfactant-induced irritation

A Novel Technique for Corneal Transepithelial Electrical Resistance Measurement in Mice

A ready-to-use integrated in vitro skin corrosion and irritation testing strategy using EpiSkin™ model in China

Multiple Computer Automated Structure Evaluation Methodology as an Alternative to In Vivo Eye Irritation Testing

Application of In Vitro Methods in Preclinical Safety Assessment of Skin Care Products

Corneal organ culture model for assessing epithelial responses to surfactants

Human relevance of in vivo and in vitro skin irritation tests for hazard classification of pesticides

Simplified ex-vivo drug evaluation in ocular surface cells: Culture on cellulose filters of cells obtained by impression cytology

Evaluation of the Safety of Cosmetic Ingredients and Their Skin Compatibility through In Silico and In Vivo Assessments of a Newly Developed Eye Serum

An epidermal equivalent assay for identification and ranking potency of contact sensitizers

Safety and Tolerability of Overdosed Artificial Tears by Abraded Rabbit Corneas

Reliability and relevance of the ES®-RHE model for in vitro skin irritation test application

Microbead-Induced Ocular Hypertensive Mouse Model For Screening And Testing Of Aqueous Production Suppressants For Glaucoma