Exploring borderline SN1–SN2 mechanisms: the role of explicit solvation protocols in the DFT investigation of isopropyl chloride

Karine Nascimento de Andrade,Bárbara Pereira Peixoto,José Walkimar de Mesquita Carneiro,Rodolfo Goetze Fiorot

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ra00066h

IF: 4.036

2024-02-06

RSC Advances

Abstract:Nucleophilic substitution at saturated carbon is a crucial class of organic reactions, playing a pivotal role in various chemical transformations that yield valuable compounds for society. Despite the well-established S N 1 and S N 2 mechanisms, secondary substrates, particularly in solvolysis reactions, often exhibit a borderline pathway. A molecular-level understanding of these processes is fundamental for developing more efficient chemical transformations. Typically, quantum-chemical simulations of the solvent medium combine explicit and implicit solvation methods. The configuration of explicit molecules can be defined through top-down approaches, such as Monte Carlo (MC) calculations for generating initial configurations, and bottom-up methods that involve user-dependent protocols to add solvent molecules around the substrate. Herein, we investigated the borderline mechanism of the hydrolysis of a secondary substrate, isopropyl chloride ( i PrCl), at DFT-M06-2X/aug-cc-pVDZ level, employing explicit and explicit + implicit protocols. Top-down and bottom-up approaches were employed to generate substrate–solvent complexes of varying number ( n = 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, and 12) and configurations of H 2 O molecules. Our findings consistently reveal that regardless of the solvation approach, the hydrolysis of i PrCl follows a loose-S N 2-like mechanism with nucleophilic solvent assistance. Increasing the water cluster around the substrate in most cases led to reaction barriers of Δ H ‡ ≈ 21 kcal mol −1 , with nine water molecules from MC configurations sufficient to describe the reaction. The More O'Ferrall–Jencks plot demonstrates an S N 1-like character for all transition state structures, showing a clear merged profile. The fragmentation activation strain analyses indicate that energy barriers are predominantly controlled by solvent–substrate interactions, supported by the leaving group stabilization assessed through CHELPG atomic charges.

chemistry, multidisciplinary

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the borderline S_N1 - SN2 mechanism of the secondary substrate isopropyl chloride in the hydrolysis reaction, especially the role of the solvent effect in this process. Specifically, the study focused on how different numbers and configurations of explicit water molecules affect the overall energy profile of isopropyl chloride hydrolysis and the properties of the transition - state structure. By comparing the initial complex configurations generated by the Monte Carlo (MC) method and the explicit microsolvation (MS) method, the paper aims to evaluate the influence of these different solvation methods on the reaction path and determine which method can more reasonably describe this complex chemical process.

### Background and Objectives of the Paper
- **Background**: Nucleophilic substitution reactions on saturated carbons are an important class of reactions in organic chemistry and are widely used in the synthesis of valuable compounds in society. Although the S_N1 and S_N2 mechanisms have been established, secondary substrates (such as substrates in solvolysis reactions) often exhibit a borderline mechanism, that is, an intermediate process between S_N1 and S_N2. Understanding these processes is crucial for the development of more efficient chemical transformations.
- **Objectives**: The main objective of this paper is to evaluate the properties of the borderline mechanism in the hydrolysis reaction of isopropyl chloride and to study how the number and configuration of explicit water molecules affect the overall energy profile and the properties of the transition - state structure. The study used two methods to generate initial complex configurations: the Monte Carlo method and the explicit microsolvation method.

### Methods
- **Theoretical Calculations**: Density functional theory (DFT), combined with the M06 - 2X functional and the aug - cc - pVDZ basis set, was used for geometric optimization and frequency calculations.
- **Solvation Models**:
- **Monte Carlo Method**: The initial distribution of solvent molecules was generated by a random method.
- **Explicit Microsolvation Method**: Solvent molecules were added step by step according to chemical intuition or molecular electrostatic potential analysis to form stable interactions.

### Results
- **Energy Profile**: Whether using the explicit or explicit + implicit solvation model, when the number of water molecules increased to 9, the activation energy barrier of the reaction stabilized at about 21 kcal/mol.
- **Transition - state Structure**: As the number of water molecules increased, the interaction between the leaving group and water molecules strengthened, resulting in a decrease in the activation energy. In particular, when the number of water molecules was 5, due to the lack of suitable water molecules as nucleophiles, the activation energy barrier of the reaction was the highest.
- **Charge Distribution**: The atomic charges in the calculated transition - state structure showed that as the number of water molecules increased, the charge density of the leaving group (Cl^-) gradually decreased, which further supported the role of water molecules in stabilizing the leaving group.

### Conclusions
- **Main Findings**: The hydrolysis reaction of isopropyl chloride follows a loose S_N2 - like mechanism in most cases, and nucleophilic solvent assistance significantly reduces the activation energy barrier of the reaction. The research results show that whether it is the Monte Carlo method or the explicit microsolvation method, when the number of water molecules is sufficient, both can reasonably describe this complex chemical process.
- **Significance**: This study provides new insights into understanding the influence of solvent effects on nucleophilic substitution reactions and is helpful for the development of more efficient chemical transformation methods.

Through the above analysis, the paper successfully explored the borderline mechanism in the hydrolysis reaction of isopropyl chloride and evaluated the effectiveness of different solvation methods.