Abstract:These findings demonstrate that among a diverse prey guild within a spatially heterogeneous environment, asymmetrical predation between a primary and secondary prey species can modulate both the magnitude of perceived risk and the strategies used to manage it, highlighting an important and understudied contingency in risk effects research. It is widely recognized that predators can influence prey through both direct consumption and by inducing costly antipredator behaviours, the latter of which can produce nonconsumptive effects that cascade through trophic systems. Yet, determining how particular prey manage risk in natural settings remains challenging as empirical studies disproportionately focus on single predator–prey dyads. Here, we contrast foraging strategies within the context of a primary and secondary prey to explore how antipredator behaviours emerge as a product of predation intensity as well as the setting in which an encounter takes place. We studied the effects of spotted owls (Strix occidentalis) on two species experiencing asymmetrical risk: dusky‐footed woodrats (Neotoma fuscipes; primary prey) and deer mice (Peromyscus spp.; alternative prey). Woodrats are most abundant within young forests, but predominantly captured by owls foraging within mature forests; in contrast, deer mice occur in high densities across forest types and seral stages and are consumed at lower per‐capita rates overall. We deployed experimental foraging patches within areas of high and low spotted owl activity, created artificial risky and safe refuge treatments, and monitored behaviour throughout the entirety of prey foraging bouts. Woodrats were more vigilant and foraged less within mature forests and at riskier patches, although the effect of refuge treatment was contingent upon forest type. In contrast, deer mice only demonstrated consistent behavioural responses to riskier refuge treatments; forest type had little effect on perceived risk or the relative importance of refuge treatment. Thus, habitat can interact with predator activity to structure antipredator responses differently for primary versus secondary prey. Our findings show that asymmetrical predation can modulate both the magnitude of perceived risk and the strategies used to manage it, thus highlighting an important and understudied contingency in risk effects research. Evaluating the direct and indirect effects of predation through the paradigm of primary and secondary prey may improve our understanding of how nonconsumptive effects can extend to population‐ and community‐level responses.

Top-down effects of intraspeciflic predator behavioral variation

Differences in prey personality mediate trophic cascades

Behavioral types of predator and prey jointly determine prey survival: potential implications for the maintenance of within-species behavioral variation

Trophic cascades regulate arthropods density and plant damage across forest strata

Phenotypes of predator individuals underpin contrasting ecosystem effects

Predators have large effects on ecosystem properties by changing plant diversity, not plant biomass

Extending trait dispersion across trophic levels: Predator assemblages act as top‐down filters on prey communities

Cascading effects of predator-detritivore interactions depend on environmental context in a Tibetan alpine meadow.

Asymmetrical predation intensity produces divergent antipredator behaviours in primary and secondary prey

Quantifying the importance of ontogeny and prey type in modeling top-down and bottom-up effects of an ectothermic predator

Predation pressure by arthropods, birds, and rodents is interactively shaped by tree species richness, vegetation structure, and season

The sign of cascading predator effects varies with prey traits in a detrital system

Predator-induced prey dispersal can cause hump-shaped density-area relationships in prey populations

Perceived predation risk affects the development of among-individual behavioral variation in a naturally clonal freshwater fish

Variations in prey consumption of centipede predators in forest soils as indicated by molecular gut content analysis

Temporal variation in tree diversity effects on birds and its implications for top-down control of insect herbivores in a tropical system

Dynamic trait distribution as a source for shifts in interaction strength and population density

Variable Bottom-Up and Top-Down Effects on Diversity of Different Prey Assemblages in an Estuarine Saltmarsh

Keystone individuals - linking predator traits to community ecology

Functional identity of dominant species in a predator community prevails over functional diversity in shaping the top‐down control of herbivores

Predator exposure early in life shapes behavioral development and individual variation in a clonal fish