Longitudinal associations of screen time, physical activity, and sleep duration with body mass index in U.S. youth

Jennifer Zink,Robert Booker,Dana L. Wolff-Hughes,Norrina B. Allen,Mercedes R. Carnethon,Shaina J. Alexandria,David Berrigan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12966-024-01587-6

2024-04-04

International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity

Abstract:Youth use different forms of screen time (e.g., streaming, gaming) that may be related to body mass index (BMI). Screen time is non-independent from other behaviors, including physical activity and sleep duration. Statistical approaches such as isotemporal substitution or compositional data analysis (CoDA) can model associations between these non-independent behaviors and health outcomes. Few studies have examined different types of screen time, physical activity, and sleep duration simultaneously in relation to BMI.

nutrition & dietetics,physiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the longitudinal association between different types of screen time (such as streaming, gaming, and social media) and body mass index (BMI) among American adolescents, taking into account the influence of physical activity and sleep duration. The study uses data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development Study, which is a nationally representative sample study comprising 10,544 American adolescents with an average age of 9.9 years.

By utilizing two statistical methods - isotemporal substitution analysis and compositional data analysis (CoDA), the study examines the combined and relative effects of screen time, physical activity, and sleep duration on BMI. Among female participants, isotemporal substitution analysis suggests that replacing 30 minutes of social media, streaming, or gaming with 30 minutes of physical activity is associated with lower BMI z-scores one year later. In male participants, replacing 30 minutes of social media, streaming, or gaming with 30 minutes of sleep is similarly related to lower BMI z-scores one year later.

Furthermore, CoDA results indicate that in male participants, higher proportions of social media time at baseline are associated with higher BMI z-scores one year later compared to other behaviors, while the proportions of physical activity and sleep duration are related to higher and lower BMI z-scores, respectively. However, no significant association between screen time and BMI was observed in female participants using CoDA analysis.

In conclusion, this study highlights that the association between screen time and BMI in a one-year longitudinal study may depend on the form of screen time, the behavior being replaced (physical activity or sleep), and the gender of the participants. Different statistical methods yield slightly different results, suggesting the need for further experimental manipulation of screen time and exploration of biopsychosocial mechanisms for causal inference, as well as providing information for intervention measures.