Abstract:Leaf area index (LAI) is a key input for many land surface models, ecological models, and yield prediction models. In order to make the model simulation and/or prediction more reliable and applicable, it is crucial to know the characteristics and uncertainties of remotely sensed LAI products before they are input into models. In this study, we conducted a comparison of four global remotely sensed LAI productsGlobal Land Surface Satellite (GLASS), Global LAI Product of Beijing Normal University (GLOBALBNU), Global LAI Map of Chinese Academy of Sciences (GLOBMAP), and Moderate-resolution Imaging Spectrometer (MODIS) LAI, while the former three products are newly developed by three Chinese research groups on the basis of the MODIS land reflectance product over China between 2001 and 2011. Direct validation by comparing the four products to ground LAI observations both globally and over China demonstrates that GLASS LAI shows the best performance, with R-2 = 0.70 and RMSE = 0.96 globally and R-2 = 0.94 and RMSE = 0.61 over China; MODIS performs worst (R-2 = 0.55, RMSE = 1.23 globally and R-2 = 0.03, RMSE = 2.12 over China), and GLOBALBNU and GLOBMAP performs moderately. Comparison of the four products shows that they are generally consistent with each other, giving the smallest spatial correlation coefficient of 0.7 and the relative standard deviation around the order of 0.3. Compared with MODIS LAI, GLOBALBNU LAI is the most similar, followed by GLASS LAI and GLOBMAP. Large differences mainly occur in southern regions of China. LAI difference analysis indicates that evergreen needleleaf forest (ENF), woody savannas (SAV) biome types and temperate dry hot summer, temperate warm summer dry winter and temperate hot summer no dry season climate types correspond to high standard deviation, while ENF and grassland (GRA) biome types and temperate warm summer dry winter and cold dry winter warm summer climate types are responsible for the large relative standard deviation of the four products. Our results indicate that although the three newly developed products have improved the accuracy of LAI estimates, much work remains to improve the LAI products especially in ENF, SAV, and GRA regions and temperate climate zones. Findings from our study can provide guidance to communities regarding the performance of different LAI products over mainland China.

Mapping Global Leaf Inclination Angle (LIA) Based on Field Measurement Data

Relationship of 2 100–2 300 Nm Spectral Characteristics of Wheat Canopy to Leaf Area Index and Leaf N As Affected by Leaf Water Content

Determination of the Leaf Inclination Angle (LIA) through Field and Remote Sensing Methods: Current Status and Future Prospects

Estimation of Leaf Area Index across Biomes and Growth Stages Combining Multiple Vegetation Indices

An overview of global leaf area index (LAI): Methods, products, validation, and applications

Quantitative Evaluation of Leaf Inclination Angle Distribution on Leaf Area Index Retrieval of Coniferous Canopies

Retrieval and validation of vertical LAI profile derived from airborne and spaceborne LiDAR data at a deciduous needleleaf forest site

Enhancing Leaf Area Index Estimation for Maize with Tower-Based Multi-Angular Spectral Observations

Assimilation of Remotely Sensed Leaf Area Index for Improving Land Surface Simulation Performance at a Global Scale

[Forest Canopy Leaf Area Index in Maoershan Mountain: Ground Measurement and Remote Sensing Retrieval].

Effects of Crop Leaf Angle on LAI-Sensitive Narrow-Band Vegetation Indices Derived from Imaging Spectroscopy

Development Of A Vegetation Index For Estimation Of Leaf Area Index Based On Simulation Modeling

One method of estimating vegetation leaf area index from ENVISAT-ASAR data

Comparison of the Spatial Characteristics of Four Remotely Sensed Leaf Area Index Products over China: Direct Validation and Relative Uncertainties.

Mapping Lai Using Brdf Model In Arid And Semi-Arid Northwestern China

Characterization and Intercomparison of Global Moderate Resolution Leaf Area Index (LAI) Products: Analysis of Climatologies and Theoretical Uncertainties

Seasonal Leaf Area Index Variations Derived from Needle Growth and Fall Measurements in Two Eastern White Pine (pinus Strobes L.) Stands

Leaf Area Index Retrieval of Orchards Based on Airborne MASTER Data

Retrieving Leaf Area Index of Forests in Red Soil Hilly Region Using Remote Sensing Data

Winter Wheat Leaf Area Index (LAI) Inversion Combining with HJ-1/CCD1 and GF-1/WFV1 Data

Evaluation of Seasonal Variations of Remotely Sensed Leaf Area Index over Five Evergreen Coniferous Forests