Abstract:The field of curriculum studies has long been tormented by a disputatious literature over theory and practice and the proper way to pursue curriculum inquiry. Roughly in the middle of the last century standard practical pursuits came into question with a dizzying array of postmodern critiques. Countering both the practical pursuits under criticism and the postmodern reconceptualist critical literature, Joseph J. Schwab advanced a theory of The Practical . Schwab’s writing remains relevant, and theoretical debates on curriculum inquiry regularly reference Schwab. These debates are driven by fundamentally different philosophical views on theory and practice and their place in curriculum studies. Although the reconceptualist literature has become theoretical orthodoxy in the field of curriculum studies, the debate is kept alive by writers who draw on Schwab’s theory of The Practical . However, little progress in mutual understanding has resulted because debate is focused on theoretical parameters, assertions, and positions at the expense of the practice of inquiry. We believe that turning attention to what people do in curriculum inquiry rather than pursuing theoretic prescriptions of how people should think in curriculum studies would help move the field forward. Our “Practical” Schwab-based work in personal practical knowledge and in narrative inquiry over the years, culminating in our current large-scale, seven-year-long longitudinal comparative education study, Reciprocal Learning Partnership Research between Canada and China, is illustrative. Using a commonplaces of inquiry framework developed by Schwab, we detail practical research qualities of The Practical and of the Reciprocal Learning Partnership Project. We discuss the situational starting and end points of curriculum inquiry in the Reciprocal Learning Partnership with special reference to the moral quality of practical situations studied. We further describe the nature of qualified knowledge outcomes in inquiry, qualities of the researcher agent, method and its relationship to a flexible, shifting database, and the understanding that inquiry and situations studied are the outcomes of narrative histories. This Schwab-based comparative education work begins with a moral position on a practical international situation and builds cross-cultural reciprocal learning strategies and outcomes using diverse theoretical positions and methodologies. In so doing Schwab’s “The Practical” is demonstrated by a new model of comparative curriculum studies. There is much to criticize in this work but there is also, we believe, much in which to take pride. Canadian and Chinese educators and their practices are enhanced through reciprocal learning . Improving practice has its own theoretical, and personal, rewards apart from the security achieved by theoretical consistency pursued by The Theoretic . Our hope is that something new in the contentious arena of curriculum studies may emerge if deliberation revolved around competing curriculum inquiry practices rather than around competing theoretical ideas on the nature of curriculum inquiry. Should this hope be unrealized, we nevertheless believe that Reciprocal Learning as an exemplar of The Practical provides useful direction for comparative curriculum studies.

Adapting and combining constructivist grounded theory and discourse analysis: A practical guide for research

“With Constructivist Grounded Theory You Can’t Hide”: Social Justice Research and Critical Inquiry in the Public Sphere

Teaching social research methods after the critical turn: challenges and benefits of a constructivist pedagogy

A Brush with Research: Teaching Grounded Theory in the Art and Design Classroom.

Discriminating among grounded theory approaches

Complicating methods for understanding educators’ language ideologies: transformative approaches for mixing methods

The Power of Constructivist Grounded Theory for Critical Inquiry

Connectivity: Person-Centred Research Principles to Inform Constructivist Grounded Theory

Discourse analysis as theory, method, and epistemology in studies of education policy

Grounded theory research: A design framework for novice researchers

Cross-cultural adaptation and user-experience validation of the ACAD Toolkit

Integrating quantitative and qualitative research: how is it done?

An Integrative Methodology for Organizational Oppositions: Aligning Grounded Theory and Discourse Analysis

The Importance of Being Attentive to Social Processes in School Bullying Research: Adopting a Constructivist Grounded Theory Approach

Teaching Theory Construction With Initial Grounded Theory Tools

Preparing Researchers to Conduct Interdisciplinary, Multi-method Qualitative Research

Working through Challenges in Doing Interview Research

How to … use theory as method in HPE research

Doing qualitative comparative research on teaching: Challenges and benefits of working with grounded theory

Reciprocal Learning as a Comparative Education Model and as an Exemplar of Schwab’s "The Practical" in Curriculum Inquiry

Integrating Discourse, Construction and Objectivity: A Contemporary Realist Approach