Abstract:Objective This study explored the longitudinal perceptions of adults with heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) enrolled in the intervention arm of an 18-month exercise clinical trial of adults with chronic, stable heart failure (n=204). Adults with HFpEF responded more favorably to the intervention with significantly improved long-term adherence to exercise (>120 minutes/week) compared to those with reduced ejection fraction. We sought to better understand what contributed to this response. Methods This qualitative descriptive study is a secondary analysis of longitudinal qualitative interviews collected during a multisite, 2-arm, randomized controlled trial of a coaching intervention to promote long-term (18 months) adherence to exercise in adults with heart failure. In the parent study, participants (n=102) in the intervention arm were interviewed at 3, 6, 12, and 18 months to gain a better understanding of experiences with exercise including barriers and facilitators. This secondary analysis included only participants with HFpEF with ≥2 interviews. Interviews were examined across participants and across time points using qualitative content analysis to develop codes that were compiled into major themes. Results Of the 27 adults with HFpEF enrolled in the intervention arm, 21 had at least 2 interviews. Our sample was 52% (11/21) male and over 47% (10/21) Black or African American. Mean age at enrollment was 63.7 ± 9.9 years. We identified 5 major themes across participants and time points including: 1. Overcoming misconceptions and attitudes - “I didn't think I could exercise. I've been proven wrong.” Most participants expressed initial fears or poor attitudes toward exercise that changed over time. 2. The exercise coach is the key ingredient - “[Coach] is working me to life.” Participants praised coaches at all interview times as key accountability partners for their success. 3. Exercise - the panacea for HFpEF symptoms and quality of life - “The more I exercise, the better I feel about everything.” Most participants expressed relief of physical and emotional symptoms with continued exercise. 4. Unmotivated to Exercise - “[Exercise] was not worth the effort” - Participants that did not participate in exercise often expressed lack of motivation or not feeling well after exercise at all time points. From the participants that actively participated in the intervention, we found our final theme - 5. Advice for others with HFpEF - “Give exercise a chance. It gets better.” Most participants expressed confidence to continue with exercise after the study and extended their gym membership or joined another exercise facility. Conclusions Most adults with HFpEF expressed benefits from participating in an exercise clinical trial including symptom relief, improved quality of life and attitudes toward exercise, and increased motivation as they continued in the study. Some participants did not actively participate and unsurprisingly, these same participants did not perceive the benefits to exercise or experience improvements in negative attitudes or motivation.

Long-term Maintenance of Exercise, Self-Efficacy, and Physiological Change in Older Adults

Exercise self-efficacy in older adults: Social, affective, and behavioral influences

Long-term Follow-Up of Physical Activity Behavior in Older Adults.

Exercise Self-Efficacy and Control Beliefs: Effects on Exercise Behavior after an Exercise Intervention for Older Adults

Factors influencing commitment to maintaining long-term exercise in adults over the age of 50

Maintained and Delayed Benefits of Executive Function Training and Low-Intensity Aerobic Exercise Over a 3.5-Year Period in Older Adults

Exercise in Middle-Aged Adults: Self-Efficacy and Self-Presentational Outcomes

“Working Me To Life” - Longitudinal Perceptions From Adults With Heart Failure With Preserved Ejection Fraction Enrolled In An Exercise Clinical Trial

Twelve-Month Retention in and Impact of Enhance®Fitness on Older Adults in Hawai'i

Long-term maintenance and effects of exercise in early psychosis

Sustainability of physical work capacity two years post outpatient cardiac rehabilitation

Long Term Physical Activity Improves Quality of Life Perception, Healthy Nutrition, and Daily Life Management in Elderly: A Randomized Controlled Trial

The Longitudinal Effects of a Lifestyle Physical Activity Intervention and a Structured Exercise Intervention on Physical Self-Perceptions and Self-Esteem in Older Adults

Theory-based Predictors of Follow-Up Exercise Behavior after a Supervised Exercise Intervention in Older Breast Cancer Survivors

Self-efficacy, Psychosocial Factors, and Exercise Behavior in Traditional Versus Modified Cardiac Rehabilitation

Responses of 49- to 59-Year-Old Sedentary, Overweight Women to Four Months of Exercise Conditioning and/or Fitness Education

The Influence of Self-rated Health on the Development of Change in the Level of Physical Activity for Participants in Prescribed Exercise

“Working me to life” – Longitudinal Perceptions from Adults with Heart Failure with Preserved Ejection Fraction Enrolled in an Exercise Training Clinical Trial

Physical activity and physique anxiety in older adults: Fitness, and efficacy influences

A self-regulation lifestyle program for post-cardiac rehabilitation patients has long-term effects on exercise adherence

Maintaining daily living activities in older adults: The impact of a functional exercise program in long-term nursing homes. A single-group pre-post intervention