High-resolution CT phenotypes in pulmonary sarcoidosis: a multinational Delphi consensus study
Sujal R Desai,Nishanth Sivarasan,Kerri A Johannson,Peter M George,Daniel A Culver,Anand Devaraj,David A Lynch,David Milne,Elisabetta Renzoni,Hilario Nunes,Nicola Sverzellati,Paolo Spagnolo,Robert P Baughman,Ruchi Yadav,Sara Piciucchi,Simon L F Walsh,Vasileios Kouranos,Athol U Wells,Sarcoid Delphi Group,Adam Anderson,Adam Morgenthau,Adrian Gaser,Alexander Vizel,Alexandra Speranskaya,Alicia Gerke,Altinisik Goksel,Alvaro Undurraga,Amita Sharma,Andrea Oh,Ann Leung,Anna Rita Larici,Antje Prasse,Antonietta Mazzei,Antonio Morais,Ashu Bhalla,Belen Del Rio,Bhavin Jankharia,Brett Elicker,Carlos Pereira,Catherine Biegelman-Aubry,Charles White,Claudia Ravaglia,Connie Hsia,Cornelia Schaefer-Prokop,David Launay,Deepak Talwar,Diego Castillo,Divya Patel,Dominique Israel-Biet,Dominique Valeyre,Edward James Britt,Elena Bargagli,Elisabeth Bendstrup,Elliott Crouser,Esther Nossent,Eugeny Shmelev,Eva Carmona Porquera,Francesco Bonella,Fleur Cohen-Aubart,Florence Jeny,Giovanni Ferrara,Gong Yong Jin,Hasti Robbie,Helmut Prosch,Hiromitsu Sumikawa,Ho Ling-Pei,Ho Yun Lee,Irina Strambu,Ivette Buendia-Roldan,Jan Grutters,Jay Ryu,Jeff Swigris,Jelle Miedema,Jin Mo Goo,Joseph Barnett,Johny Verschakelen,Jonathan Goldin,Joon Beom Seo,Juan Enghelmayer,Juan Mana,Juergen Behr,Karen Patterson,Katerina Antoniou,Kevin Brown,Kiminori Fujimoto,Laurent Savale,Lisa Maier,Luca Richeldi,Manuel Lessa Ribeiro Neto,Marc Humbert,Marc Judson,Marcel Veltkamp,Margaret Wilsher,Maria Molina,Maria Otaola,Marie-Pierre Revel,Mario Silva,Marjolein Drent,Mark Schiebler,Marlies Wijsenbeek-Lourens,Martina Bonifazi,Martine Remy-Jardin,Matthew Koslow,Meyer Balter,Michael Kreuter,Muhunthan Thillai,Nabeel Hamzeh,Nazia Chaudhuri,Nesrin Mogulkoc,Nevins Todd,Nick Screaton,Nicole Goh,Nirav Shah,Ogugua Obi,Oksana Shlobin,Olga Baranova,Paul Bresser,Paula Rottoli,Pierre-Yves Brillet,Qonita Said-Hartley,Raphael Borie,Remy Mostard,Richard van Zyl-Smit,Ronaldo Kairalla,Ryoko Egashira,Samia Boussouar,Sang Min Lee,Sanjeev Bhalla,Sara Tomassetti,Silvia Quadrelli,Simon P Hart,Sonye Danoff,Sujeet Rajan,Sun Mi Choi,Susan Copley,Tae Jung Kim,Takeshi Johkoh,Tamera Corte,Theresa McLoud,Thomas Wessendorf,Tiago Alfaro,Toru Arai,Ulrich Costabel,Vanesa Vicens-Zygmunt,Venerino Poletti,Vincent Cottin,Violeta Vucinic,Wim Wuyts,Wouter van Es,Yeon Joo Jeong,Yoshikazu Inoue
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(23)00267-9
Abstract:One view of sarcoidosis is that the term covers many different diseases. However, no classification framework exists for the future exploration of pathogenetic pathways, genetic or trigger predilections, patterns of lung function impairment, or treatment separations, or for the development of diagnostic algorithms or relevant outcome measures. We aimed to establish agreement on high-resolution CT (HRCT) phenotypic separations in sarcoidosis to anchor future CT research through a multinational two-round Delphi consensus process. Delphi participants included members of the Fleischner Society and the World Association of Sarcoidosis and other Granulomatous Disorders, as well as members' nominees. 146 individuals (98 chest physicians, 48 thoracic radiologists) from 28 countries took part, 144 of whom completed both Delphi rounds. After rating of 35 Delphi statements on a five-point Likert scale, consensus was achieved for 22 (63%) statements. There was 97% agreement on the existence of distinct HRCT phenotypes, with seven HRCT phenotypes that were categorised by participants as non-fibrotic or likely to be fibrotic. The international consensus reached in this Delphi exercise justifies the formulation of a CT classification as a basis for the possible definition of separate diseases. Further refinement of phenotypes with rapidly achievable CT studies is now needed to underpin the development of a formal classification of sarcoidosis.