Does the Geographic Difference of Soil Properties Matter for Setting Up the Soil Screening Levels in Large Countries Like China?

Yang Wang,Shijie Wang,Lin Jiang,Lin Ma,Xiaoyan Li,Maosheng Zhong,Wenyu Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.1c08771

2022-04-20

Abstract:China issued the unified national soil screening levels (NSSLs) in 2018 to assist the regulation of contaminated sites, but the applicability of NSSLs was not thoroughly evaluated. Datasets from the National Qinghai-Tibet Plateau Scientific Data Center indicated great variability of soil organic matter (0.8-173 g/kg), soil water content (0.05-0.6), soil porosity (0.4-0.6), and soil bulk density (1.11-1.59 kg/m³). We analyzed the effects of soil properties on the derivation of SSLs by using Monte Carlo simulations. The soil factors mainly affected the inhalation exposure pathway of volatile organic compounds (VOCs). They had an effect of more than two orders of magnitude on SSLs for most selected VOCs, particularly with the parameters 0.35 > Henry's law constant > 0.1 and carbon-water distribution coefficient of >100. We compared NSSLs with the recommended SSLs assuming fifth percentile by using Monte Carlo simulations. In general, NSSLs were not sufficient to identify contaminated sites that require additional investigation in the south, central, and northwest regions but were too conservative in screening sites out that required no further action in the east and northeast regions. Our framework and findings may contribute to more scientific and effective soil quality management in other large countries.

environmental sciences,engineering, environmental