Abstract:The extent to which the brain predicts upcoming information during language processing remains controversial. To shed light on this debate, the present study reanalyzed Nieuwland and colleagues' (2018) [Nieuwland, M. S., Politzer-Ahles, S., Heyselaar, E., Segaert, K., Darley, E., Kazanina, N., et al. Large-scale replication study reveals a limit on probabilistic prediction in language comprehension. eLife, 7, e33468, 2018] replication of DeLong and colleagues (2015) [DeLong, K. A., Urbach, T. P., & Kutas, M. Probabilistic word pre-activation during language comprehension inferred from electrical brain activity. Nature Neuroscience, 8, 1117–1121, 2005]. Participants (n = 356) viewed sentences containing articles and nouns of varying predictability, while their EEG was recorded. We measured ERPs preceding the critical words (namely, the semantic prediction potential), in conjunction with postword N400 patterns and individual neural metrics. ERP activity was compared with two measures of word predictability: cloze probability and lexical surprisal. In contrast to prior literature, semantic prediction potential amplitudes did not increase as cloze probability increased, suggesting that the component may not reflect prediction during natural language processing. Initial N400 results at the article provided evidence against phonological prediction in language, in line with Nieuwland and colleagues' findings. Strikingly, however, when the surprisal of the prior words in the sentence was included in the analysis, increases in article surprisal were associated with increased N400 amplitudes, consistent with prediction accounts. This relationship between surprisal and N400 amplitude was not observed when the surprisal of the two prior words was low, suggesting that expectation violations at the article may be overlooked under highly predictable conditions. Individual alpha frequency also modulated the relationship between article surprisal and the N400, emphasizing the importance of individual neural factors for prediction. The present study extends upon existing neurocognitive models of language and prediction more generally, by illuminating the flexible and subject-specific nature of predictive processing.

Language prediction in monolingual and bilingual speakers: an EEG study

Prediction in Challenging Situations: Most Bilinguals Can Predict Upcoming Semantically-Related Words in Their L1 Source Language when Interpreting

Prior Context and Individual Alpha Frequency Influence Predictive Processing during Language Comprehension

Early language dissociation in bilingual minds: magnetoencephalography evidence through a machine learning approach

Prior context and individual alpha frequency (IAF) influence predictive processing during language comprehension

Understanding language-elicited EEG data by predicting it from a fine-tuned language model

Language experience shapes predictive coding of rhythmic sound sequences

EEG decoding of spoken words in bilingual listeners: from words to language invariant semantic-conceptual representations

The relationship between speech in noise perception and auditory working memory capacity in monolingual and bilingual adults

Prediction of Second Language Proficiency Based on Electroencephalographic Signals Measured While Listening to Natural Speech

A hierarchy of linguistic predictions during natural language comprehension

Predicting coarse-grained semantic features in language comprehension: evidence from ERP representational similarity analysis and Chinese classifier

Decoding bilingualism from resting-state oscillatory network organization

An EEG Study of Bilingual Brain by Picture Naming Paradigm

On predicting others’ words: Electrophysiological evidence of prediction in speech production

Predictive influences on memory encoding: investigating oscillations and the N400 event-related potential component

Event-related Potential Measures of Visual Word Processing in Monolingual and Bilingual Children and Adults: A Focus on Word Frequency Effects

The prediction potential indexes the meaning and communicative function of upcoming utterances

Spatiotemporal Dynamics of Predictive Brain Mechanisms During Speech Processing: an MEG Study.