Nutritional composition of ultra-processed plant-based foods in the out-of-home environment: a multi-country survey with plant-based burgers

R.E. Vellinga,H.L. Rippin,G.B. Gonzales,E.H.M. Temme,C. Farrand,A. Halloran,B. Clough,K. Wickramasinghe,M. Santos,T. Fontes,M.J. Pires,A.C Nascimento,S. Santiago,H.E. Burt,M.K. Brown,H.K. Jenner,R. Alessandrini,A.M. Marczak,R. Flore,Y. Sun,C. Motta
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0007114524000023
2024-01-16
British Journal Of Nutrition
Abstract:Ultra-processed plant-based foods, such as plant-based burgers have gained in popularity. Particularly in the out-of-home (OOH) environment, evidence regarding their nutritional profile and environmental sustainability is still evolving. Plant-based burgers available at selected OOH sites were randomly sampled in cities of four WHO European Member States; Amsterdam, Copenhagen, Lisbon, and London. Plant-based burgers (patty, bread and condiment) (n=41) were lab-analysed for their energy, macronutrients, amino acids, and minerals content per 100g and serving, and were compared with reference values. For the plant-based burgers, the median values per 100g were: 234 kcal, 20.8g carbohydrates, 3.5g dietary fibre, and 12.0g fat, including 0.08g TFA and 2.2g SFA. Protein content was 8.9g/100g, with low protein quality according to amino acid composition. Median sodium content was 389mg/100g, equivalent to 1g salt. Compared with references, the median serving of plant-based burgers provided 31% of energy intake based on a 2,000 kcal per day, and contributed to carbohydrates(17-28%), dietary fibre(42%), protein(40%), total fat(48%), SFA(26%), and sodium(54%). One serving provided 15-23% of the reference values for calcium, potassium, and magnesium, while higher contributions were found for zinc(30%), manganese(38%), phosphorus(51%), and iron(67%). The ultra-processed plant-based burgers, provide protein, dietary fibre and essential minerals, but also contain relatively high levels of energy, sodium, and total fats. The amino acid composition of the plant-based burgers indicated low protein quality. The multifaceted nutritional profile of plant-based burgers highlights the need for manufacturers to implement improvements to better support healthy dietary habits. These improvements should include reducing energy, sodium and total fats.
nutrition & dietetics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of exploring the nutritional content of ultra-processed plant-based foods (using plant-based burgers as an example) in dining-out environments and their impact on healthy eating habits. Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Nutritional Content Analysis**: Through laboratory analysis, nutritional information was obtained from plant-based burger samples from four cities: Amsterdam in the Netherlands, Copenhagen in Denmark, Lisbon in Portugal, and London in the United Kingdom. This includes energy, macronutrients, amino acids, and mineral content. 2. **Nutritional Quality Assessment**: The study found that while these plant-based burgers provide protein, dietary fiber, and essential minerals, they also contain high levels of energy, sodium, and total fat, which may not be beneficial for health. 3. **Amino Acid Composition**: The paper also analyzed the amino acid composition of the plant-based burgers, revealing that their protein quality is relatively low, particularly in terms of certain essential amino acids (such as sulfur-containing amino acids). 4. **Health Impact Discussion**: The authors discussed the risk factors of these foods for non-communicable diseases (NCDs) and pointed out that although plant-based burgers have certain health benefits, their high salt and fat content may offset some of these benefits. 5. **Policy Recommendations**: Finally, the study emphasized the need for manufacturers to improve formulations by reducing energy, sodium, and fat content to better support healthy eating habits. It also suggested that relevant policymakers should make decisions based on such research findings.