Transcriptomic profiling of osteoarthritis synovial macrophages reveals a tolerized phenotype compounded by a weak corticosteroid response

Cheng Wang,Ruben De Francesco,Lieke A Lamers,Sybren Rinzema,Siebren Frölich,Peter L E M van Lent,Colin Logie,Martijn H J van den Bosch

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/rheumatology/keae161

2024-03-11

Rheumatology

Abstract:Abstract Objectives It is well-known that long-term osteoarthritis prognosis is not improved by corticosteroid treatments. Here we investigate what could underlie this phenomenon by measuring the short term corticosteroid response of OA-Mf. Methods We determined the genome-wide transcriptomic response to corticosteroids of end-stage osteoarthritic joint synovial macrophages (OA-Mf). This was compared with LPS-tolerized and β-glucan-trained circulating blood monocyte-derived macrophage models. Results Upon corticosteroid stimulation, the trained and tolerized macrophages significantly alter the abundance of 201 and 257 RNA transcripts, respectively. By contrast, by the same criteria, OA-Mf have a very restricted corticosteroid response of only 12 RNA transcripts. Furthermore, while metalloproteinases 1, -2, -3 and -10 expression clearly distinguish OA-Mf from both the tolerized and trained macrophage models, OA-Mf Interleukin 1 (IL1), chemokine (CXCL) and cytokine (CCL) family member profiles resemble the tolerized macrophage model, with the exception that OA-Mf show high levels of CCL20. Conclusion Terminal osteoarthritis joints therefore harbor macrophages with an inflammatory state that closely resembles the tolerized macrophage state and this is compounded by a weak corticosteroid response capacity that may explain the lack of positive long-term effects of corticosteroid treatment for osteoarthritis patients.

rheumatology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore why long - term use of corticosteroid treatment fails to improve the prognosis of patients with osteoarthritis (OA). Specifically, the researchers investigated the reasons behind this phenomenon by measuring the short - term response of synovial macrophages in osteoarthritis patients (OA - Mf) to corticosteroids. The study found that, compared with models of circulating blood monocyte - derived macrophages that had been made tolerant to lipopolysaccharide (LPS) or trained with β - glucan, the response of OA - Mf to corticosteroids was very limited, which may be one of the reasons for the poor long - term efficacy of corticosteroid treatment in osteoarthritis patients.

### Main research questions
1. **Why can't corticosteroid treatment improve the long - term prognosis of osteoarthritis patients?**
- The researchers explored this question by comparing the response of OA - Mf to corticosteroids with that of other model macrophages (such as LPS - tolerant and β - glucan - trained macrophages).

2. **What are the inflammatory state of OA - Mf and the characteristics of its response to corticosteroids?**
- The researchers revealed the inflammatory state of OA - Mf and its response pattern to corticosteroids through transcriptome analysis.

### Research methods
- **Sample source**: Synovial tissue was isolated from advanced osteoarthritis patients undergoing joint replacement surgery, and OA - Mf was purified from it.
- **Experimental design**: OA - Mf was divided into two groups, one was exposed to the synthetic corticosteroid triamcinolone acetonide (TA), and the other was only exposed to the solvent DMSO.
- **Control group**: Circulating blood monocyte - derived macrophages that had been made tolerant to LPS and trained with β - glucan were used as controls.
- **Transcriptome analysis**: Gene expression changes in macrophages under different treatment conditions were analyzed by RNA sequencing technology.

### Main findings
- **The corticosteroid response of OA - Mf is very limited**: Compared with LPS - tolerant and β - glucan - trained macrophages, the response of OA - Mf to corticosteroids was very weak, with only 12 RNA transcripts significantly altered.
- **Expression pattern of inflammation - related genes**: The expression pattern of OA - Mf in the IL - 1 family, CCL cytokines and CXCL chemokines was similar to that of LPS - tolerant macrophages, but its inhibitory response to corticosteroids was weaker.
- **Expression of the MMP gene family**: OA - Mf showed a unique MMP gene expression pattern, especially high expression of MMP1, MMP2, MMP3 and MMP10, which were expressed at lower levels in healthy circulating blood monocyte - derived macrophages.

### Conclusions
- **OA - Mf has an inflammatory state similar to that of LPS - tolerant macrophages** and a weaker ability to respond to corticosteroids, which may be one of the reasons for the poor long - term efficacy of corticosteroid treatment in osteoarthritis patients.

Through these findings, the researchers provided important scientific basis for further understanding the pathological mechanism of osteoarthritis and developing more effective treatment methods.