Techno-economic analysis for biomass supply chain: A state-of-the-art review

Shirleen Lee Yuen Lo,Bing Shen How,Wei Dong Leong,Sin Yong Teng,Muhammad Akbar Rhamdhani,Jaka Sunarso
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2020.110164
IF: 16.799
2021-01-01
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
Abstract:<p>Given the increasing risk of climate change and depletion of non-renewable energy sources, countries around the world have been looking into energy profile diversification whereby biomass represents one of the most appealing alternatives for energy production feedstock. To attract interest and more investment from industry players into biomass-based industries, comprehensive techno-economic analysis has to be performed. In addition, various uncertainties related to supply chain such as biomass attainability, demand variation, and material price fluctuation, have to be considered in the evaluation to yield more accurate and reliable feasibility estimation. This review paper aims to: (i) provide an overview on the different types of methods or approaches used in the feasibility evaluation of biomass-based industries from the techno-economic point of view, and (ii) outline the supply chain uncertainties that should be incorporated into the evaluation model using a Malaysian case study to illustrate the impact of these uncertainties. Apart from that, some of the unquantifiable uncertainties and risks are critically reviewed in this paper. It was found that 78 % of the reviewed articles opted for mathematical modelling evaluation method with the majority leaning towards mathematical modelling with optimization (i.e., deterministic and stochastic optimization). Furthermore, only a minority had performed stochastic evaluation that incorporates biomass supply chain uncertainties. This review discussed six quantifiable uncertainties, include: (i) biomass availability, (ii) biomass quality, (iii) transportation cost, (iv) market demand, (v) fluctuation of pricing, and (vi) wages of workers.</p>
energy & fuels,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main aim of this paper is to address the technical and economic assessment issues in the biomass energy supply chain and to explore the impact of supply chain uncertainties on the feasibility of the biomass industry. Specifically, the objectives of the paper include: 1. **Overview of Methods and Approaches**: Provide an overview of different types of methods or approaches used to assess the techno-economic feasibility of the biomass industry. This involves how to evaluate the feasibility of the biomass industry from both technical and economic perspectives. 2. **Incorporating Uncertainty into Assessment Models**: Outline the supply chain uncertainties that should be included in the assessment models, illustrated through a case study in Malaysia. The paper mentions 6 quantifiable uncertainty factors, including biomass availability, quality, transportation costs, market demand, price fluctuations, and labor wages. 3. **Critical Review**: Conduct a critical review of some uncertainties and risks that are difficult to quantify. 4. **Mathematical Modeling and Optimization**: Analysis shows that 78% of the literature chose mathematical modeling methods for assessment, with most preferring deterministic and stochastic optimization mathematical modeling. Additionally, only a few papers conducted stochastic assessments considering biomass supply chain uncertainties. 5. **Quantifying the Impact of Uncertainties**: Discuss the 6 quantifiable uncertainty factors and their impact on the techno-economic feasibility of the biomass industry. The uniqueness of this review paper lies in its comprehensive overview of various methods used for techno-economic analysis of the biomass supply chain, with a particular focus on the impact of uncertainty factors on the feasibility of the biomass supply chain. The paper emphasizes the importance of considering these uncertainties in the assessment process and provides historical data as a basis for future research.