Abstract:The world’s terrestrial biomes are broadly classified according to the dominant plant growth forms that define ecosystem structure and processes. Although the abundance and distribution of different plant growth forms can be strongly determined by factors such as climate and soil composition, large mammalian herbivores have a strong impact on plant communities, thus defaunation (the local or functional extinction of large animals) has the potential to alter the compositional structure of plant growth forms in natural ecosystems. Tropical rainforests sustain a high diversity of growth forms, including trees, palms, lianas, shrubs, herbs and bamboos, all of which play important ecosystem functions. Here, we experimentally evaluate how large mammalian herbivores affect the dominance, diversity and coexistence of these major tropical forest plant growth forms, by monitoring communities of saplings on the understorey in 43 paired exclusion plots in a long‐term replicated exclusion experiment in the understorey of the Atlantic forest of Brazil. Over the course of 10 years large herbivore exclusion decreased diversity among growth forms, increased the absolute abundance of palms and trees (22% and 38% respectively) and increased the diversity of species within these two groups, to the detriment of other growth forms. Furthermore, all pairwise relationships between growth forms were positive on plots where herbivores had access, whereas several strong negative relationships emerged in plots where herbivores were excluded. This occurred despite strong background directional temporal trends affecting plant communities in both experimental treatments across the region. Synthesis. Our work indicates that the defaunation alters growth form dominance by favouring palms and trees while eroding diversity among growth forms and coexistence on a temporal scale. Large herbivore mammals promote diversity among growth forms, preventing the hyper‐dominance of trees and palms, yet without supressing the diversity of species within growth forms. We argue that large herbivore mammals affect growth forms through several non‐mutually exclusive mechanisms, including herbivory, seed dispersal and physical disturbance, as well as differential effects linked to the morphological and physiological adaptations of growth forms. We conclude that defaunation might lead to profound impacts on important ecosystem functions underpinned by growth form diversity, and result in vertical and horizontal structural simplification of tropical rainforests. Os biomas terrestres ao redor do mundo podem ser amplamente classificados de acordo com as formas de vida das plantas, as quais podem definir a estrutura e os processos ecossistêmicos. Embora a abundância e distribuição de diferentes formas de vida de plantas possam ser fortemente determinadas por fatores como clima e composição do solo, os grandes mamíferos herbívoros também têm um forte impacto nas comunidades vegetais, assim a defaunação (a extinção local ou funcional de grandes animais) tem o potencial de alterar a composição das formas de vida das plantas em ecossistemas naturais. As florestas tropicais sustentam uma alta diversidade de formas de vida de plantas, incluindo árvores, palmeiras, lianas, arbustos, ervas e bambus, as quais desempenham importantes funções ecossistêmicas. Nesse trabalho, avaliamos experimentalmente como grandes mamíferos herbívoros afetam a dominância, diversidade e coexistência dessas principais formas de vida de plantas das florestas tropicais, monitorando comunidades de plântulas no sub‐bosque em 43 pares de parcelas em um experimento de exclusão de longo prazo no sub‐bosque da Mata Atlântica brasileira. Nós encontramos que ao longo de 10 anos, a exclusão de grandes herbívoros diminuiu a diversidade entre as formas de vida das plantas, aumentando a abundância absoluta de palmeiras e árvores (22% e 38%, respectivamente) e aumentando a diversidade de espécies dentro desses dois grupos, em detrimento da outras formas de vida. Além disso, todas as interações pareadas entre as formas de vida foram positivas nas parcelas onde os herbívoros tiveram acesso, enquanto várias relações negativas fortes surgiram nas parcelas onde os herbívoros foram excluídos. Discutimos que isso ocorreu devido a vários fatores temporais atuando simultaneamente, que afetaram as comunidades de plantas em ambos os tratamentos experimentais em todas as regiões. Nosso trabalho indica que numa escala temporal a defaunação altera a dominância das formas de vida das plantas, favorecendo palmeiras e árvores enquanto diminui a diversidade e a coexistência entre as os outros grupos de plantas. Os grandes mamíferos herbívoros tiveram um papel essencial em promover a diversidade entre esses grupos de plantas, evitando assim a hiperdominância de árvores e palmeiras sem suprimir a diversidade de espécies dentro das formas de vida. Nós discutimos que esses herbívoros afetam as formas de vida de plantas através de vários mecanismos, incluindo herbivoria, dispersão de sementes e distúrbios físicos, bem como através de mecanismos relacionados às adaptações morfológicas e fisiológicas desses grupos de plantas. Nós concluímos que a defaunação pode levar a impactos profundos e importantes nas funções ecossistêmicas mantidas pela diversidade de formas de vida de plantas, resultando numa simplificação estrutural vertical e horizontal das florestas tropicais. Our work indicates that the defaunation alters growth form dominance by favouring palms and trees while eroding diversity among growth forms and coexistence on a temporal scale. Large herbivore mammals promote diversity among growth forms, preventing the hyper‐dominance of trees and palms, yet without supressing the diversity of species within growth forms. We argue that large herbivore mammals affect growth forms through several non‐mutually exclusive mechanisms, including herbivory, seed dispersal and physical disturbance, as well as differential effects linked to the morphological and physiological adaptations of growth forms. We conclude that defaunation might lead to profound impacts on important ecosystem functions underpinned by growth form diversity, and results in vertical and horizontal structural simplification of tropical rainforests.

Defaunation impacts on the carbon balance of tropical forests

Contrasting effects of defaunation on aboveground carbon storage across the global tropics

The need for carbon finance schemes to tackle overexploitation of tropical forest wildlife

Defaunation of large-bodied frugivores reduces carbon storage in a tropical forest of Southeast Asia

Large mammalian herbivores modulate plant growth form diversity in a tropical rainforest

Unintended consequences of planting native and non‐native trees in treeless ecosystems to mitigate climate change

Deforestation-induced climate change reduces carbon storage in remaining tropical forests

The Unseen Effects of Deforestation: Biophysical Effects on Climate

Using historical habitat loss to predict contemporary mammal extirpations in Neotropical forests

Net loss of biomass predicted for tropical biomes in a changing climate

Habitat differences in seed‐dispersing vertebrates indicate dispersal limitation in tropical bracken‐dominated deforested areas

Re-appraisal of the global climatic role of natural forests for improved climate projections and policies

Amazon forests a net carbon source during drought and under high rates of human-disturbance

The interplay between defaunation and phylogenetic diversity affects leaf damage by natural enemies in tropical plants

Seed‐dispersal mode and habitat connectivity underpin variation in carbon stocking between Brazilian biomes

Ecological erosion of an Afrotropical forest and potential consequences for tree recruitment and forest biomass

Loss of species and functions in a deforested megadiverse tropical forest

The tropical forest carbon cycle and climate change

Carbon Dynamics in a Human-Modified Tropical Forest: A Case Study Using Multi-Temporal LiDAR Data

Global forestation and deforestation affect remote climate via adjusted atmosphere and ocean circulation

Tropical Forest Protection, Uncertainty, and the Environmental Integrity of Carbon Mitigation Policies