Hemicolectomy versus appendectomy for patients with appendiceal neuroendocrine tumours 1-2 cm in size: a retrospective, Europe-wide, pooled cohort study
Cédric Nesti,Konstantin Bräutigam,Marta Benavent,Laura Bernal,Hessa Boharoon,Johan Botling,Antonin Bouroumeau,Iva Brcic,Maximilian Brunner,Guillaume Cadiot,Maria Camara,Emanuel Christ,Thomas Clerici,Ashley K Clift,Hamish Clouston,Lorenzo Cobianchi,Jarosław B Ćwikła,Kosmas Daskalakis,Andrea Frilling,Rocio Garcia-Carbonero,Simona Grozinsky-Glasberg,Jorge Hernando,Valérie Hervieu,Johannes Hofland,Pernille Holmager,Frediano Inzani,Henning Jann,Paula Jimenez-Fonseca,Enes Kaçmaz,Daniel Kaemmerer,Gregory Kaltsas,Branislav Klimacek,Ulrich Knigge,Agnieszka Kolasińska-Ćwikła,Walter Kolb,Beata Kos-Kudła,Catarina Alisa Kunze,Stefania Landolfi,Stefano La Rosa,Carlos López López,Kerstin Lorenz,Maurice Matter,Peter Mazal,Claudia Mestre-Alagarda,Patricia Morales Del Burgo,Els J M Nieveen van Dijkum,Kira Oleinikov,Lorenzo A Orci,Francesco Panzuto,Marianne Pavel,Marine Perrier,Henrik Mikael Reims,Guido Rindi,Anja Rinke,Maria Rinzivillo,Xavier Sagaert,Ilker Satiroglu,Andreas Selberherr,Alexander R Siebenhüner,Margot E T Tesselaar,Michael J Thalhammer,Espen Thiis-Evensen,Christos Toumpanakis,Timon Vandamme,José G van den Berg,Alessandro Vanoli,Marie-Louise F van Velthuysen,Chris Verslype,Stephan A Vorburger,Alessandro Lugli,John Ramage,Marcel Zwahlen,Aurel Perren,Reto M Kaderli
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S1470-2045(22)00750-1
Abstract:Background: Awareness of the potential global overtreatment of patients with appendiceal neuroendocrine tumours (NETs) of 1-2 cm in size by performing oncological resections is increasing, but the rarity of this tumour has impeded clear recommendations to date. We aimed to assess the malignant potential of appendiceal NETs of 1-2 cm in size in patients with or without right-sided hemicolectomy. Methods: In this retrospective cohort study, we pooled data from 40 hospitals in 15 European countries for patients of any age and Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status with a histopathologically confirmed appendiceal NET of 1-2 cm in size who had a complete resection of the primary tumour between Jan 1, 2000, and Dec 31, 2010. Patients either had an appendectomy only or an appendectomy with oncological right-sided hemicolectomy or ileocecal resection. Predefined primary outcomes were the frequency of distant metastases and tumour-related mortality. Secondary outcomes included the frequency of regional lymph node metastases, the association between regional lymph node metastases and histopathological risk factors, and overall survival with or without right-sided hemicolectomy. Cox proportional hazards regression was used to estimate the relative all-cause mortality hazard associated with right-sided hemicolectomy compared with appendectomy alone. This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT03852693. Findings: 282 patients with suspected appendiceal tumours were identified, of whom 278 with an appendiceal NET of 1-2 cm in size were included. 163 (59%) had an appendectomy and 115 (41%) had a right-sided hemicolectomy, 110 (40%) were men, 168 (60%) were women, and mean age at initial surgery was 36·0 years (SD 18·2). Median follow-up was 13·0 years (IQR 11·0-15·6). After centralised histopathological review, appendiceal NETs were classified as a possible or probable primary tumour in two (1%) of 278 patients with distant peritoneal metastases and in two (1%) 278 patients with distant metastases in the liver. All metastases were diagnosed synchronously with no tumour-related deaths during follow-up. Regional lymph node metastases were found in 22 (20%) of 112 patients with right-sided hemicolectomy with available data. On the basis of histopathological risk factors, we estimated that 12·8% (95% CI 6·5 -21·1) of patients undergoing appendectomy probably had residual regional lymph node metastases. Overall survival was similar between patients with appendectomy and right-sided hemicolectomy (adjusted hazard ratio 0·88 [95% CI 0·36-2·17]; p=0·71). Interpretation: This study provides evidence that right-sided hemicolectomy is not indicated after complete resection of an appendiceal NET of 1-2 cm in size by appendectomy, that regional lymph node metastases of appendiceal NETs are clinically irrelevant, and that an additional postoperative exclusion of metastases and histopathological evaluation of risk factors is not supported by the presented results. These findings should inform consensus best practice guidelines for this patient cohort. Funding: Swiss Cancer Research foundation.