Structure-Based Design, Virtual Screening, and Discovery of Novel Patulin Derivatives as Biogenic Photosystem II Inhibiting Herbicides

He Wang,Jing Zhang,Yu Ji,Yanjing Guo,Qing Liu,Yuan Chang,Sheng Qiang,Shiguo Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/plants13121710
2024-06-20
Plants
Abstract:Computer-aided design usually gives inspirations and has become a vital strategy to develop novel pesticides through reconstructing natural lead compounds. Patulin, an unsaturated heterocyclic lactone mycotoxin, is a new natural PSII inhibitor and shows significant herbicidal activity to various weeds. However, some evidence, especially the health concern, prevents it from developing as a bioherbicide. In this work, molecular docking and toxicity risk prediction are combined to construct interaction models between the ligand and acceptor, and design and screen novel derivatives. Based on the analysis of a constructed patulin–Arabidopsis D1 protein docking model, in total, 81 derivatives are designed and ranked according to quantitative estimates of drug-likeness (QED) values and free energies. Among the newly designed derivatives, forty-five derivatives with better affinities than patulin are screened to further evaluate their toxicology. Finally, it is indicated that four patulin derivatives, D3, D6, D34, and D67, with higher binding affinity but lower toxicity than patulin have a great potential to develop as new herbicides with improved potency.
plant sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to discover new parthenolide derivatives as biogenic photosystem II inhibitor herbicides through structural design and virtual screening. Specifically, researchers are concerned with how to modify the structure of the natural compound parthenolide by computer - aided design methods to improve its herbicidal activity and reduce toxicity, thereby developing new, highly efficient and low - toxicity herbicides. ### Background and Problems 1. **Characteristics of Parthenolide** - Parthenolide is an unsaturated heterocyclic lactone mycotoxin with significant herbicidal activity, especially showing a strong inhibitory effect on invasive weeds such as *Ageratina adenophora*. - However, parthenolide has health risks, such as genotoxicity, embryotoxicity, cytotoxicity, neurotoxicity, immunotoxicity, carcinogenicity and teratogenicity, which limit its application as a biopesticide. 2. **Research Objectives** - Discover new parthenolide derivatives through structural design and virtual screening, and these derivatives should have higher binding affinity and lower toxicity. - Use molecular docking and toxicity risk prediction to construct an interaction model between ligands and receptors, and design and screen new derivatives. ### Methods and Results 1. **Molecular Docking** - Use the crystal structure of Arabidopsis thaliana D1 protein (PDB: 5MDX) to simulate the binding mode of parthenolide at the Q B site. - Identify the key residues that bind to parthenolide, such as Phe211, Met214, Leu218, His252, Phe255, Ser264, Phe265, Leu271, Phe274 and Leu275. In particular, His252 binds to the O2 carbonyl oxygen atom of parthenolide through a hydrogen bond. 2. **Design and Screening** - Design 81 parthenolide derivatives, which introduce different substituents at the 1-, C3, C4, 5-, C6 or C7 positions. - Screen out 45 derivatives with higher binding affinity than parthenolide through molecular docking and binding energy calculation. - Further evaluate the toxicity risks of these derivatives, and finally determine that four derivatives (D3, D6, D34 and D67) have higher binding affinity and lower toxicity, showing the potential for development as new herbicides. ### Conclusion Through structural design and virtual screening, researchers have successfully discovered several new parthenolide derivatives. These derivatives not only have higher herbicidal activity but also lower toxicity, and are expected to become a new generation of highly efficient herbicides. This research provides important theoretical basis and technical support for the development of new biogenic herbicides.