Occurrence, tissue distribution, and risk assessment of progestins, androgens, estrogens, and phenols in wild freshwater fish species

Xinyi Zhou,Zhaoguang Yang,Fangyuan Peng,Yang Liu,Yi Lu,Haipu Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-023-29889-5
IF: 5.8
2023-09-19
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
Abstract:The presence of endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) in aquatic environments such as water, sediment, and sludge received more and more attention. However, the bioaccumulate properties of EDCs, particularly progestins and androgens, in various tissues of different wild freshwater fish species, as well as their effects on human health, have not been fully studied. The muscle, liver, and gills of three wild fish species obtained from the East Dongting Lake in southern China were examined for the presence of 19 EDCs (4 progestins, 5 androgens, 6 estrogens, and 4 phenols). Seventeen analytes were detected in all fish samples, and the concentrations of progestins, androgens, estrogens, and phenols ranged from ND–78.80 ng/g (wet weight, ww), ND–50.40 ng/g ww, ND–3573.82 ng/g ww, and ND–88.17 ng/g ww, respectively. The bioaccumulation of some EDCs in wild fish from East Dongting Lake was species-specific. Additionally, AND, EES, P4, and E2 were discovered in the liver at higher levels than in the muscle, suggesting that livers had a larger ability for enriching these EDCs than the muscle. Furthermore, the relationships between the fish sizes and the EDC concentrations indicated that total weight and length had a negligible impact on the bioaccumulation of EDCs in various fish species. Most importantly, the effects of EDCs on human health as a result of fish consumption were assessed. Although the estimated daily intakes (EDIs) of most EDCs were much lower compared with the corresponding acceptable daily intakes (ADIs) via consuming fish collected in this study, the EDI of EE2 in Silurus asotus was higher than the ADI of E2, indicating that Silurus asotus from East Dongting Lake should be eaten in moderation by local residents.
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper mainly explores the distribution, tissue accumulation of endocrine - disrupting chemicals (EDCs) in wild freshwater fish in the East Dongting Lake and their potential risks to human health. Specifically, the paper attempts to solve the following problems: 1. **Types and concentrations of EDCs**: - The presence and concentration ranges of 19 types of EDCs (4 progestogens, 5 androgens, 6 estrogens and 4 phenolic compounds) in the muscles, livers and gills of three wild freshwater fish (grass carp *Ctenopharyngodon idella*, crucian carp *Carassius auratus* and yellow catfish *Silurus asotus*) were studied. 2. **Bio - accumulation characteristics**: - The bio - accumulation characteristics of EDCs in different fish and different tissues, especially those of progestogens and androgens, which have been relatively less studied in the environment, were analyzed. 3. **Tissue distribution**: - The distribution of EDCs in different tissues (muscles, livers and gills) was explored, especially the enrichment ability in the liver. 4. **Relationship between fish size and EDCs concentration**: - The relationship between the size (total length and total weight) of different fish and the concentration of EDCs was investigated to understand the impact of fish growth on EDCs accumulation. 5. **Human health risk assessment**: - The health risks to local residents from consuming these contaminated fish were assessed by estimating the estimated daily intake (EDI) and the acceptable daily intake (ADI). ### Main findings - **Presence and concentration of EDCs**: - 17 types of EDCs were detected. Among them, the concentrations of progestogen P4, androgen AND, estrogens EE2 and E2 in the liver were significantly higher than those in the muscles, indicating that the liver has a strong enrichment ability for these EDCs. - The detection frequency of estrogen DES was the highest, although it has been banned in China since 2011. - **Bio - accumulation characteristics**: - The bio - accumulation of EDCs by different fish is species - specific. For example, the grass carp has a higher ability to accumulate certain EDCs than the other two fish. - The liver is the main organ for EDCs enrichment, especially for androgen AND and estrogens EE2, P4 and E2. - **Tissue distribution**: - The concentrations of EDCs in different tissues vary significantly, and the concentrations in the liver are generally higher than those in the muscles and gills. - **Relationship between fish size and EDCs concentration**: - Overall, the size of fish has a relatively small impact on the bio - accumulation of EDCs, but the concentrations of some EDCs (such as P4, BPA, MT and HEX) are positively or negatively correlated with fish growth. - **Human health risk assessment**: - The EDI of most EDCs is far lower than the corresponding ADI, indicating that the health risks from consuming these fish are low. However, the EDI of EE2 in yellow catfish exceeds the ADI of E2, and it is recommended that local residents consume yellow catfish in moderation. Through these studies, the paper provides an important scientific basis for understanding the behavior of EDCs in freshwater ecosystems and their potential impacts on human health.