Abstract:Background: The chiral magnetic effect (CME) is extensively studied in heavy-ion collisions at the BNL Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) and the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). An azimuthal correlator called RΨm was proposed to measure the CME. By observing the same RΨ2 and RΨ3 (convex) distributions from A Multi-Phase Transport (ampt) model, by contrasting data and model as well as large and small systems and by event shape engineering (ESE), a recent preprint (arXiv:2006.04251v1) from STAR suggests that the RΨm observable is sensitive to the CME signal and relatively insensitive to backgrounds, and their Au+Au data are inconsistent with known background contributions. Purpose: We examine those claims by studying the robustness of the RΨm observable using ampt as well as toy model simulations. We compare RΨm to the more widely used Δγ azimuthal correlator to identify their commonalities and differences. Methods: We use ampt to simulate Au+Au, p+Au, and d+Au collisions at sNN=200GeV, and study the responses of RΨm to anisotropic flow backgrounds in the model. We also use a toy model to simulate resonance flow background and input CME signal to investigate their effects in RΨ2. Additionally we use the toy model to perform an ESE analysis to compare with STAR data as well as predict the degree of sensitivity of RΨ2 to isobar collisions with the event statistics taken at RHIC. Results: Our ampt results show that the RΨ2 in Au+Au collisions is concave and apparently different from RΨ3, in contradiction to the findings in STAR's preprint, while the RΨ2 in p+Au and d+Au collisions are slightly concave. Our toy model ESE analysis indicates that the RΨ2 is sensitive to the event-by-event anisotropy q2 as well as the elliptic flow parameter v2. The toy model results further show that RΨ2 depends on both the CME signal and the flow backgrounds, similar to the Δγ observable. It is found that the RΨ2 and Δγ observables show similar sensitivities and centrality dependencies in isobar collisions. Conclusions: Our ampt results contradict those from a recent preprint by STAR. Our toy model simulations demonstrate that RΨ2 is sensitive to both the CME signal and physics backgrounds. Toy model simulations of isobar collisions show similar centrality dependence and magnitudes for the relative RΨ2 strengths as well as the relative Δγ strengths. We conclude that RΨ2 and the inclusive Δγ are essentially the same.

Search for the chiral magnetic effect in collisions between two isobars with deformed and neutron-rich nuclear structures

Testing the Chiral Magnetic Effect with Isobaric Collisions

Revisit the chiral magnetic effect expectation in isobaric collisions at the relativistic heavy ion collider

Deciphering the R Ψ m correlator in search for the chiral magnetic effect in relativistic heavy ion collisions

Signatures of Chiral Magnetic Effect in the Collisions of Isobars

Upper Limit on the Chiral Magnetic Effect in Isobar Collisions at the Relativistic Heavy-Ion Collider

Decipher the $R_{Ψ_{m}}$ correlator in search for the chiral magnetic effect in relativistic heavy ion collisions

Estimate of Background Baseline and Upper Limit on the Chiral Magnetic Effect in Isobar Collisions at $\sqrt{s_{\text{NN}}}=200$ GeV at the Relativistic Heavy-Ion Collider

Chiral Magnetic Effect in Isobaric Collisions from Anomalous-Viscous Fluid Dynamics (AVFD)

Exploring the chiral magnetic effect in isobar collisions through Chiral Anomaly Transport

Predictions for isobaric collisions at $\sqrt{s_{_{\rm NN}}}$ = 200 GeV from a multiphase transport model

Ultrarelativistic Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions ( Quark Matter 2018 ) Re-examining the premise of isobaric collisions and a novel method to measure the chiral magnetic e ff ect

Difference between signal and background of the chiral magnetic effect relative to spectator and participant planes in isobar collisions at GeV

Search for the Chiral Magnetic Effect Via Two-plane Method in Isobar Collisions

Predictions For Isobaric Collisions At Root&Itsnn&It=200 Gev From A Multiphase Transport Model

Search for the Chiral Magnetic Effect using Sliding Dumbbell Method in Isobar Collisions ($^{96}_{44}Ru$+$^{96}_{44}Ru$ and $^{96}_{40}Zr$+$^{96}_{40}Zr$) at RHIC

Constraining the chiral magnetic effect using spectator and participant planes across Au+Au and isobar collisions at $\sqrt{s_{_{\rm NN}}} = 200$ GeV

International Conference on Ultrarelativistic Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions ( Quark Matter 2018 ) Chiral Magnetic E ff ect in Isobaric Collisions from Anomalous-Viscous Fluid Dynamics ( AVFD )

Difference between signal and background of the chiral magnetic effect relative to spectator and participant planes in isobar collisions at $\sqrt{s_{_{\rm NN}}} = 200$ GeV

Impact of globally spin-aligned vector mesons on the search for the chiral magnetic effect in heavy-ion collisions

Impact of magnetic-field fluctuations on measurements of the chiral magnetic effect in collisions of isobaric nuclei