Helically Coiled Tube Flocculators in Water Clarification Systems: Optimal Length Evaluation and Process Efficiency Probabilistic Analysis

Danieli S. Oliveira,Clainer B. Donadel
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16052172
IF: 3.9
2024-03-07
Sustainability
Abstract:New sustainable technologies have been explored as potential solutions to address the global issue of water scarcity by enhancing water treatment processes. In this context, an innovative coagulation/flocculation unit known as the helically coiled tube flocculator (HCTF) has emerged, offering notable advantages such as high process efficiency, short detention time, and cost-effectiveness compared to conventional hydraulic units. The HCTF harnesses its flow energy to disperse coagulation/flocculation agents and facilitate the formation of flocs through collisions between destabilized particles. This paper introduces an assessment of the process efficiency, geometric properties, and hydraulic characteristics of an alternative and sustainable water clarification system incorporating an HCTF, with the aim of determining its optimal length. In HCTFs, the flocculator's length (referred to as L) can exert a significant influence on process efficiency, necessitating a comprehensive evaluation of this parameter for the rational design of such units. To accomplish this, the paper scrutinizes physical experimental findings from previous research articles, which are related to the efficiency of flocculation (indirectly estimated by analyzing turbidity removal efficiency). Additionally, it examines the geometric and hydraulic attributes across 48 distinct variations of HCTFs. This study culminates in the development of a model for determining the optimal length for HCTFs. Furthermore, it includes a probabilistic assessment that establishes a connection between the optimal length and other parameters involved in the clarification process—whether deterministic or probabilistic—and their impact on the final process efficiency, all with a 90% confidence level. This paper stands out by pioneering the determination of the optimal length of HCTFs, filling a gap in the existing literature, which previously only mentioned the importance of this parameter in process efficiency without providing a predictive model. The results highlight the robustness of the proposed alternative clarification system. Even in scenarios with substantial variations in dimensional hydraulic parameters (such as a worst-case relative standard deviation of 20%), the process efficiency fluctuations range between 1.3% and 5.2%. These outcomes lend support to the adoption of such alternative water clarification systems. They also underscore the potential of probabilistic evaluation as a valuable tool for investigating novel water and wastewater treatment units and enhancing existing ones.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine the optimal length of the Helically Coiled Tube Flocculator (HCTF) in the water clarification system and evaluate the influence of this parameter on the treatment efficiency. Specifically, the paper aims to: 1. **Develop a prediction model**: Through physical experimental data and mathematical modeling, establish a model that can predict the optimal length of HCTF. This model fills the gap in the existing literature, because although previous literature has mentioned the importance of length to treatment efficiency, it has not provided specific prediction methods. 2. **Conduct probability analysis**: Through the probability analysis method, study the relationship between the optimal length and other parameters affecting the clarification process, including deterministic and probabilistic parameters, and evaluate the influence of these parameters on the final treatment efficiency. The paper uses a 90% confidence level for analysis to ensure the reliability of the results. 3. **Improve treatment efficiency**: By optimizing the length of HCTF, improve the treatment efficiency of the water clarification system. Even when the hydraulic parameters fluctuate greatly (such as when the relative standard deviation reaches 20%), the fluctuation range of the treatment efficiency is only between 1.3% and 5.2%, which indicates that the system has high robustness. ### Main research contents - **Physical experiment**: Conduct experiments using HCTF with different geometric and hydraulic characteristics to evaluate its influence on turbidity removal efficiency. - **Mathematical modeling**: Based on the experimental data, establish a linear regression model to relate the turbidity removal efficiency to dimensionless parameters (such as Reynolds number, Camp number, etc.). - **Probability analysis**: Consider the hydraulic parameters as independent probability variables, and model through the probability density function to evaluate the influence of these parameters on the treatment efficiency. ### Key formulas - **Turbidity removal efficiency**: \[ E_f(\%)=\left(1 - \frac{\text{Residual turbidity}}{\text{Initial turbidity}}\right)\times100 \] - **Reynolds number**: \[ Re = \frac{\rho\cdot v\cdot d}{\mu} \] - **Camp number**: \[ Ca = G\cdot T=\frac{\rho\cdot g\cdot h_F}{\mu\cdot T\cdot V}\cdot\frac{L}{Q} \] - **Derivative of the optimal length**: \[ \frac{dE_f}{dL}=E_f'=-\frac{c_2 G\pi d^2}{4Q}+\frac{c_4 p}{L^2} = 0 \] The solution is: \[ L_{\text{critical}}=\sqrt{\frac{c_4 p}{c_{10}}} \] where \( c_{10}=\frac{c_2 G\pi d^2}{4Q} \) ### Conclusion Through physical experiments and mathematical modeling, the paper has successfully established a model for predicting the optimal length of HCTF, and verified the reliability and robustness of this model through probability analysis. These results support the application prospect of HCTF as an efficient and economical water clarification technology.