Phuong Thanh LeHassan F. GholipourAmir Arjomandia Faculty of Economics and Management,Thuyloi University,Hanoi,Vietnamb School of Business,Western Sydney University,Parramatta,Australiac School of Business,Faculty of Business and Law,University of Wollongong,Wollongong,Australia
Abstract:This article investigates the relationship between bank competition and stability within a transitioning economy, focusing on Vietnamese banks from 2007 to 2018. Set against the backdrop of a transformative banking landscape post the collapse of the socialist bloc, the article utilises the Lerner Index to measure bank competition. The Z-score is used as a measure of bank stability. Panel fixed effects and difference GMM estimations suggest that heightened competition correlates positively with bank stability. Notably, these dynamics hold true even after omitting state-owned banks, signifying that government-controlled banks do not exclusively drive the observed relationships. Policymakers, hence, face the crucial task of balancing liberalisation efforts with safeguarding bank stability and emphasising the need for robust risk management and strong corporate governance in transitioning economies dominated by public ownership. This article thus offers valuable insights for policy refinement in similarly poised nations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the relationship between bank competition and bank stability in the context of economic transformation. Specifically, the paper focuses on the changes in competition and stability in the Vietnamese banking industry from 2007 to 2018, and explores how bank competition affects bank stability during the process of financial liberalization. The paper pays special attention to the specific manifestations of this relationship and its impact on policy - making in transition economies where public ownership still dominates.
### Background Information
1. **Economic Transformation Background**: The paper mentions that the disintegration of the socialist camp in the late 1990s triggered the transformation of former planned - economy countries to market economies. In this process, the banking industry has changed from a single - level system (where the central bank operates as a commercial bank at the same time) to a two - level system (an independent central bank and commercial banks). This transformation is accompanied by liberalization efforts aimed at improving the efficiency and competitiveness of the banking industry, allowing domestic private and foreign investors to participate.
2. **Special Situation in Vietnam**: Different from the comprehensive transformation in post - communist European countries, China and Vietnam have adopted a restricted transformation path, and public ownership still dominates in the banking industry. The government implements specific policies through these banks, such as providing credit to state - owned enterprises or supporting remote areas and infrastructure projects.
3. **Contradiction between Competition and Stability**: Although liberalization can enhance the competitiveness of the banking industry, stability is still the primary concern of the government. Therefore, policy - makers must balance the relationship between liberalization measures and bank stability to ensure that the stability of the banking system is not endangered by excessive competition.
### Research Objectives
The main objectives of the paper are:
- **Explore the Impact of Bank Competition on Stability**: Use data from the Vietnamese banking industry to analyze the relationship between bank competition (measured by the Lerner index) and bank stability (measured by the Z - score).
- **Evaluate the Impact of Liberalization**: In the context of financial liberalization, evaluate the performance of different types of banks (including state - owned banks and private banks) in terms of competition and stability.
### Methodology
- **Competition Measurement**: Use the Lerner index to measure the degree of bank competition. The Lerner index is defined as the ratio of price over marginal cost, ranging from 0 to 1, and a value closer to 0 indicates a more competitive market.
- **Stability Measurement**: Use the Z - score to measure bank stability. The formula for calculating the Z - score is:
\[
Z_{s,t}=\frac{ROA_{s,t}+\left(\frac{E_{s,t}}{TA_{s,t}}\right)}{\sigma_{ROA}}
\]
where \( ROA_{s,t} \) is the return on assets, \( \frac{E_{s,t}}{TA_{s,t}} \) is the ratio of equity to total assets, and \( \sigma_{ROA} \) is the standard deviation of the return on assets. The higher the Z - score, the better the bank's stability.
- **Empirical Model**: Adopt the panel fixed - effect model and the Difference GMM (Difference Generalized Method of Moments) method for estimation. The basic model is as follows:
\[
Z - score_{s,t}=\beta_1\times\text{Lerner Index}_{s,t}+\beta_2\times X_{s,t}+v_s+\mu_t+u_{s,t}
\]
where \( Z - score \) is the dependent variable, representing bank stability; the Lerner Index is the main explanatory variable, representing the degree of bank competition; \( X_{s,t} \) is the control variable, including the ratio of loans to total assets, bank size, and the ratio of total cost to total assets.
### Conclusions
The research results of the paper show that in Vietnam, there is a positive correlation between bank competition and bank stability. Even when state - owned banks are excluded, this relationship still holds, indicating that government - controlled banks are not the only driving factor. This finding is of great significance to policy - makers, especially in balancing liberalization measures and bank stability.