Preference of C2v Symmetry in Low-Spin Hexacarbonyls of Rare-Earth and f Elements

Attila Kovács,Werner Klotzbücher

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/sym16020178

2024-02-03

Symmetry

Abstract:The structures and bonding of selected neutral M(CO)6 complexes (M = Sc, Y, La, Lu, Ac and U) have been studied by density functional theory calculations. The calculations revealed the preference for C2v symmetry and low-spin electronic state for most of these complexes. The relative stability of the low-symmetry species increases gradually with the size of the metal atom. While the characteristic Oh hexa-coordinated structure is favored in the high-spin electronic state of the smaller metals, for heavier metals, important advantages of the C2v vs. Oh structures include larger charge transfer interactions in terms of transferred electrons as well as better steric conditions. Our joint experimental–theoretical analysis detected and confirmed the Oh structure of the Sc(CO)6 complex in cryogenic CO/Ar matrices.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the structural preferences and bonding characteristics of hexacarbonyl complexes of rare - earth elements and f - block elements (M(CO)₆, where M is Sc, Y, La, Lu, Ac, U) in the low - spin state. Specifically, the authors studied the structures and electronic states of these complexes through density functional theory (DFT) calculations and found that they tend to form C₂ᵥ structures with lower symmetry rather than the usually expected high - symmetry Oₕ structures. In addition, the paper also explored the changes in the relative stabilities of these complexes under different metal atom sizes and analyzed the reasons for this structural preference, including charge - transfer interactions and steric hindrance effects.

### Main research contents:
1. **Structural preference**:
- The paper revealed through DFT calculations that these hexacarbonyl complexes are more likely to form C₂ᵥ symmetry structures rather than Oₕ symmetry structures in the low - spin state.
- As the size of the metal atom increases, the stability of the low - symmetry structure gradually increases.

2. **Bonding characteristics**:
- The authors used the natural bond orbital (NBO) analysis method to study the donor - acceptor interactions between the ligands and the metal, including CO→M σ donation and M→CO π feedback.
- For heavier metals, the C₂ᵥ structure has greater charge - transfer interactions and better steric hindrance conditions.

3. **Experimental verification**:
- Through matrix - isolation infrared spectroscopy (IR) and ultraviolet spectroscopy (UV) experiments, the authors detected and confirmed the Oₕ structure of the Sc(CO)₆ complex in a low - temperature CO/Ar matrix.

### Key conclusions:
- **Structural preference**: Most hexacarbonyl complexes are more likely to form C₂ᵥ structures in the low - spin state, especially for heavier metals.
- **Stability**: As the size of the metal atom increases, the stability of the C₂ᵥ structure gradually increases.
- **Bonding mechanism**: The advantage of the C₂ᵥ structure lies in greater charge - transfer interactions and better steric hindrance conditions.

### Research significance:
- This study deepens the understanding of the structures and bonding characteristics of hexacarbonyl complexes of rare - earth elements and f - block elements, providing a theoretical basis and experimental evidence for further research in related fields.