A sky view evaluation of the impact of mini-grid projects on progress towards SDG7
Jean-Claude BerthelemyMathilde Maurela Centre d'Économie de la Sorbonne,University Paris 1,Paris,Franceb FERDI (Fondation pour les Etudes et la Recherche sur le Développement International),Clermont-Ferrand,Francec Centre d'Économie de la Sorbonne,CNRS and University Paris 1,Paris,FranceJean-Claude Berthélemy is Emeritus Professor at University Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne,former Director of the Sorbonne School of Economics,Corresponding Member of the Institut de France and Senior Fellow at FERDI. He has published extensively in academic journals on Development Economics over the past 40 years,investigating various research topics: economic growth,aid effectiveness development traps,development finance,human resources and sustainable development,with a geographical focus on Africa. He has developed at FERDI a research programme on SDG7 in which he has introduced the use of remote sensing in impact evaluations of electrification programmes.Mathilde Maurel,who mainly works for the CNRS as a research director and teaches at the University of Paris 1 Panthéon Sorbonne,is also senior researcher at FERDI and was recently elected a member of the AE (Academia Europaea). Her research focuses on major economic and societal issues using advanced econometric techniques,and she has worked on a variety of subjects: the EU's enlargement,environmental issues such as climate-induced migration,the effectiveness of China's environmental policies,and the importance of infrastructure such as decentralised electricity in achieving the MDGs. She also attempts to explore issues surrounding the formation of norms,institutions and political behaviour. To date,her research has been published in journals such as the Journal of Comparative Economics,Public Choice,Review of World Economics,Climate Policy,The Journal of Development Studies,Applied Economics,Economic Systems,World Development.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19439342.2024.2309376
2024-02-01
Journal of Development Effectiveness
Abstract:This paper proposes an evaluation study of the impact of mini-grid electrification projects on SDG7 (ensure access to affordable, reliable, sustainable and modern energy for all). Questioning the effectiveness of mini-grid development programmes on electricity access is essential because we have observed many failed cases in which the mini-grids stopped delivering on their promises a few years after commissioning the equipment. Our approach is based on night-time light (NTL) data. The methodology is designed and tested using mini-grid projects precisely localised and documented in published papers. We compare NTL data for each project before and after commissioning. We show that in about half the projects, NTL detects significant positive changes after commissioning. We build a test of impact, which confirms the causal nature of the observed effects of mini-grid projects on progress being made in SDG7, based on a comparison between non-treated localities matched with treated localities. But the domain of validity of this conclusion has limitations, related in particular to remoteness, extreme initial energy poverty and insufficient inclusiveness. These factors should be considered in the design of mini-grid development programmes.
development studies