Abstract:Meta-heuristic algorithms (MHAs) have gained popularity in recent years due to their successful results in solving a wide variety of scientific problems. They offer ease of use, fast implementation, and effective convergence toward the optimal solution. Although MHAs have been extensively tested in solving well-known mathematical benchmark problems with one or more dimensions as well as civil and mechanical engineering problems in their initial demonstrations, controller design problems are not typically considered. Furthermore, the literature lacks a standardized optimization process for controller design problems using MHAs. Due to variations in iteration numbers, population sizes, number of trials, objective functions, and insufficient analysis presented in research papers, it becomes challenging to compare and evaluate the controller design performance of MHAs in a successful and fair manner. This work aims to establish a standardized approach for evaluating the performance of MHAs in controller design by proposing a consistent function evaluation metric. To achieve this goal, we present the most comprehensive and comparative study of MHAs' performance in controller design conducted to date. In this paper, we utilize two commonly used objective functions in controller design: Zwe Lee Gaing and Integral Time Absolute Error. Additionally, we employ a total of twenty algorithms, consisting of ten classical algorithms and ten recently popular algorithms. We evaluate the performance of these algorithms on the "automatic voltage regulation" electric power system problem, which serves as a widely used benchmark for meta-heuristically optimized controllers. We consider three different controllers with three (PID), five (FOPID), and seven (FOPIDD) parameters. The performance results of the selected algorithms are thoroughly discussed, considering various analysis techniques such as box plot analysis, convergence curves, and transient response performances, as well as statistical tests like Wilcoxon and Friedman tests. As a result, symbiotic organisms search, teaching–learning based optimization, chaos game optimization, supply–demand based optimization, and jellyfish search algorithms generally emerge as the best-performing algorithms across all optimization processes for the three types of controllers. Researchers interested in conducting further analysis and comparing the improved algorithms can access all the models,parameters, and codes used in this study from the provided link (https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/161336-fractional-order-controller-optimization-for-avr).

Refined sinh cosh optimizer tuned controller design for enhanced stability of automatic voltage regulation

A Digital Dual-Mode Lqr Optimal Controller for Boost Converter over A Wide Operation Range

An intelligent tuning scheme with a master/slave approach for efficient control of the automatic voltage regulator

Development of AVR controller performance using exponential distribution and transit search optimization techniques

Optimizing AVR system performance via a novel cascaded RPIDD2-FOPI controller and QWGBO approach

Optimal design of controller for automatic voltage regulator performance enhancement: a survey

On the assessment of meta-heuristic algorithms for automatic voltage regulator system controller design: a standardization process

Incorporation of stochastic fractal search algorithm into efficient design of PID controller for an automatic voltage regulator system

Modified and Improved TID Controller for Automatic Voltage Regulator Systems

Fractional High-Order Differential Feedback Controller Based on Meta-Heuristic Algorithms for Automatic Voltage Regulator

Enhancement of AVR system performance by using hybrid harmony search and dwarf mongoose optimization algorithms

Designing Heuristic-Based Tuners for Fractional-Order PID Controllers in Automatic Voltage Regulator Systems Using a Hyper-Heuristic Approach

Robust control of automatic voltage regulator (AVR) with real structured parametric uncertainties based on H∞ and μ-analysis

An optimal design for an automatic voltage regulation system using a multivariable PID controller based on hybrid simulated annealing – white shark optimization

A Novel Salp Swarm Optimization Oriented 3-DOF-PIDA Controller Design for Automatic Voltage Regulator System

Novel hVsaGwo algorithm for non-linear dynamic weighted state feedback with 1DOF-PID based controllers in AVR

Optimal fractional order PID controller design for automatic voltage regulator system based on reference model using particle swarm optimization

Robust Model Predictive Control Paradigm for Automatic Voltage Regulators against Uncertainty Based on Optimization Algorithms

Performance and robustness analysis of V-Tiger PID controller for automatic voltage regulator

Design and robustness analysis of fuzzy PID controller for automatic voltage regulator system using genetic algorithm

Optimal Control of AVR System With Tree Seed Algorithm-Based PID Controller