Abstract:<p>The term "confidence" is often used in relation to economic issues, and has been increasingly discussed in the media and by policy makers since the 2008 global financial crisis. However, the question remains of whether confidence actually affects economic growth. Using panel data on 41 countries from 1991 to 2017, we study how consumer and business confidence affect economic growth. We find that confidence positively affects economic growth, and that this effect is amplified during recessions and in low-confidence situations. Further analysis shows that confidence has a greater effect during recessions by amplifying the effect of monetary and fiscal policies. The results of generalized method of moments analysis prove the robustness of the main findings. In general, our study reveals that confidence plays a significant role in the economy, thus supporting the notion that governments should give more consideration to confidence when trying to stimulate the economy.</p>
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the impact of confidence on economic growth, especially to analyze from the perspective of policy effectiveness how consumer confidence and business confidence affect economic growth. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:
1. **Asymmetric Effects of Confidence on Economic Growth**: The study finds that confidence has a more significant impact on economic growth during economic recessions, that is, confidence is more important when the economy is in a slump. This indicates that during economic recessions, restoring confidence is more important than in normal times.
2. **Through Which Channels Does Confidence Affect the Economy**: The paper further explores how confidence affects economic growth by magnifying the effects of fiscal and monetary policies. The research results show that during economic recessions, a higher level of confidence can enhance the effects of fiscal and monetary policies, thereby promoting economic growth.
3. **The Roles of Consumer Confidence and Business Confidence**: The paper not only focuses on consumer confidence but also particularly emphasizes the important role of business confidence in economic fluctuations. The study finds that both consumer confidence and business confidence have a significant positive impact on economic growth, but the impact of consumer confidence is more significant.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
1. **Revealing the Asymmetric Effects of Confidence**: The paper provides strong empirical evidence to prove that confidence plays a more significant role during economic recessions, which provides a theoretical basis for policymakers to pay more attention to confidence during economic recessions.
2. **Expanding the Research on Fiscal and Monetary Policies**: Through empirical analysis, the paper proves that confidence affects economic growth by magnifying the effects of fiscal and monetary policies, which provides a new perspective for understanding the effectiveness of policies.
3. **Attaching Importance to the Role of Business Confidence**: In addition to consumer confidence, the paper also emphasizes the importance of business confidence in economic fluctuations, filling the gap in the existing research where there is insufficient attention to business confidence.
### Research Methods
The paper uses panel data from 41 countries from 1991 to 2017 and conducts regression analysis to study the impact of confidence on economic growth. The main regression model is as follows:
\[ Y_{i,t} = \alpha_0 + \alpha_1 \text{Confidence}_{i,t} + \alpha_2 X_{i,t} + \eta_i + \phi_t + \epsilon_{i,t} \]
where:
- \( Y_{i,t} \) is the dependent variable, representing the GDP growth rate, consumption growth rate or investment growth rate of country \( i \) in year \( t \).
- \( \text{Confidence}_{i,t} \) is the independent variable, representing the overall confidence level of country \( i \) in year \( t \), using the Business Confidence Index (BCI) and the Consumer Confidence Index (CCI) as proxy variables.
- \( X_{i,t} \) is the control variable, including the inflation rate, the proportion of industrial added value in GDP, the proportion of trade volume in GDP, the age - dependency ratio, the population growth rate and the domestic savings rate.
- \( \eta_i \) is the country - fixed effect, and \( \phi_t \) is the year - fixed effect.
To further test through which channels confidence affects economic growth, the paper constructs the following regression model:
\[ Y_{i,t} = \beta_0 + \beta_1 \text{Confidence}_{i,t} + \beta_2 \text{Confidence}_{i,t} \times \text{Policy}_{i,t} + \beta_3 \text{Policy}_{i,t} + \beta_4 X_{i,t} + \eta_i + \phi_t + \epsilon_{i,t} \]
where:
- \( \text{Policy}_{i,t} \) represents fiscal or monetary policy, using multiple variables as proxies, such as policy interest rate, inter - bank interest rate, money supply growth rate, central government debt, government debt, fiscal balance and basic balance, etc.
### Conclusions
Through empirical analysis, the paper proves that confidence has a significant positive impact on economic growth, especially during economic recessions. In addition, confidence magnifies fiscal and monetary policies.