Abstract:Background: Probe tube placement is an important skill audiologists must learn to make real-ear measurements in an audiology clinic. With current evidence-based guidelines recommending insertion of the probe tube within 5 mm of the tympanic membrane (TM) for proper acoustical measurements, students must be well trained to ensure they are capable to perform this placement in clinical practice. This is not always the case as it has been found that real-ear measurements are not performed in a clinic as often as required. To address this, a simulator consisting of a 3D-printed ear model and an optical tracking system was developed to provide a training system for students to practice probe tube placement and to provide a method to evaluate competency before starting clinical practicum placements. Two simulators were developed, an adult model and a pediatric model. Purpose: To assess the face and content validity of the two probe tube placement simulators (adult and pediatric) and define barriers and facilitators to implementing this system into an educational setting. Research design: Participants followed the setup and operating instructions designed to guide them through each functionality of the simulator. A questionnaire was used to assess face and content validity, applicability to an educational setting, and to determine perceived barriers and facilitators to using the probe tube simulators for training purposes. Five additional probe tube placements with each simulator were performed in which distance-to-TM was recorded. Study sample: Twelve participants with significant probe tube placement experience. Data collection and analysis: Participants rated each question in the questionnaire from 0% to 100% depending on their level of agreement. Averages and standard deviations (SDs) were compiled and presented for each section (face validity, content validity, and applicability to an educational setting). Final facilitators and barriers for the simulator were compiled and the top answers of each are presented. The five quantitative probe tube placement measurements for each participant were averaged, SDs were calculated, and contacts with the TM while placing the probe tube were recorded. Results: The average face validity score over all questions for the adult model was 65% (SD = 18.2) whereas the pediatric model received a score of 64% (16.4). The overall content validity average score was 78.7% (17) and applicability to an educational setting had an average score of 80% (5.33). The average distance-to-TM across all trials and participants was 3.74 mm (1.82) for the adult model and 2.77 mm (0.94) for the pediatric model with only one participant exceeding the recommended maximum of 5 mm. Listed shortcomings of the current simulator included realism of the 3D-printed ear, ease of insertion of an otoscope tip into the ear, ability to visualize the ear canal "landmarks" and the TM, and foam tip insertion experience. Conclusions: Results were generally very positive for the simulator, and future iterations will look to improve the flexibility and texture of the ear, as well as the otoscopic view of the ear canal and TM.

"Seeing inside out": revealing the effectiveness of otoscopy training in virtual reality enhanced practical exams - a randomized controlled trial

Simulator approaches in otorhinolaryngology ‐ Looking beyond the ophthalmological horizon

Gathering Validity Evidence for a Simulation-Based Test of Otoscopy Skills

The assessment of virtual reality training in antromastoidectomy simulation

Simulator-Based Versus Traditional Training of Fundus Biomicroscopy for Medical Students: A Prospective Randomized Trial

A Structured Approach to the Development and Evaluation of a Virtual Reality Eye Examination Simulation

Virtual Reality Simulator: Unveiling the "Inner" Skills of Endoscopists

Pedagogical evaluation of an augmented reality thoracentesis simulator for the training of medical students.

Face and Content Validity of a Probe Tube Placement Training Simulator

An observer tool to enhance learning of incoming anesthesia residents' skills during simulation training of central venous catheter insertion: a randomized controlled trial

Assessing REALTER simulator: analysis of ocular movements in simulated low-vision conditions with extended reality technology

Virtual Quality Control in Middle Ear Surgery: Is Image-guided Tympanoscopy a Valuable Tool for Depicting Borderline Situations?

Ultra-high-fidelity virtual reality mastoidectomy simulation training: a randomized, controlled trial

Efficacy of Virtual Preparation Simulators Compared to Traditional Preparations on Phantom Heads

Video Otoscopy as a Novel Teaching and Remote Otolaryngology Consultation Tool at an Academic Medical Center

Virtual Reality Simulation for the Middle Cranial Fossa Approach: A Validation Study

Design and Evaluation of a Virtual Reality Simulation Module for Training Advanced Temporal Bone Surgery

Virtual reality simulation training in laparoscopic surgery – does it really matter, what simulator to use? Results of a cross-sectional study

Specificity of motor learning in simulator training of endoscopic-surgery skills

Comparing the impact of surgical expert versus non‐ophthalmologist instructors on virtual‐reality surgical performance: A randomized controlled trial

Initial Validation of a Virtual-Reality Learning Environment for Prostate Biopsies: Realism Matters!