Abstract:Medical Decision Making, Ahead of Print. Theory—understanding mental processes that drive decisions—is important to help patients and providers make decisions that reflect medical advances and personal values. Building on a 2008 review, we summarize current tenets of fuzzy-trace theory (FTT) in light of new evidence that provides insight regarding mental representations of options and how such representations connect to values and evoke emotions. We discuss implications for communicating risks, preventing risky behaviors, discouraging misinformation, and choosing appropriate treatments. Findings suggest that simple, fuzzy but meaningful gist representations of information often determine decisions. Within minutes of conversing with their doctor, reading a health-related web post, or processing other health information, patients rely on gist memories of that information rather than verbatim details. This fuzzy-processing preference explains puzzles and paradoxes in how patients (and sometimes providers) think about probabilities (e.g., "50-50" chance), outcomes of treatment (e.g., with antibiotics), experiences of pain, end-of-life decisions, memories for medication instructions, symptoms of concussion, and transmission of viruses (e.g., in AIDS and COVID-19). As examples, participation in clinical trials or seeking treatments with low probabilities of success (e.g., with antibiotics or at the end of life) may indicate a defensibly different categorical gist perspective on risk as opposed to simply misunderstanding probabilities or failing to make prescribed tradeoffs. Thus, FTT explains why people avoid precise tradeoffs despite computing them. Facilitating gist representations of information offers an alternative approach that goes beyond providing uninterpreted "neutral" facts versus persuading or shifting the balance between fast versus slow thinking (or emotion vs. cognition). In contrast to either taking mental shortcuts or deliberating about details, gist processing facilitates application of advanced knowledge and deeply held values to choices.HighlightsFuzzy-trace theory (FTT) supports practical approaches to improving health and medicine.FTT differs in important respects from other theories of decision making, which has implications for how to help patients, providers, and health communicators.Gist mental representations emphasize categorical distinctions, reflect understanding in context, and help cue values relevant to health and patient care.Understanding the science behind theory is crucial for evidence-based medicine.

What Makes the Time Tradeoff Tick? A Sociopsychological Explanation

Modifying the Composite Time Trade-Off Method to Improve Its Discriminatory Power

Focus theory of normative conduct and terror-management theory: The interactive impact of mortality salience and norm salience on social judgment.

Selfless Time

Adjusting to Death: the Effects of Mortality Salience and Self-Esteem on Psychological Well-Being, Growth Motivation, and Maladaptive Behavior

Reverse time-to-death as time-scale in time-to-event analysis for studies of advanced illness and palliative care

Prosocial Attitudes toward Money from Terror Management Perspective: Death Transcendence through Spirituality

Another way to measure balanced time perspective: Development and validation of the Time Perspective Inventory

Mitigating death anxiety: Identifying music’s role in terror management

Perceived Consensus, Uniqueness, and Terror Management: Compensatory Responses to Threats to Inclusion and Distinctiveness Following Mortality Salience

Medical maximization: The effect of personality on triage decision-making

Terror mismanagement: evidence that mortality salience exacerbates phobic and compulsive behaviors

Examining Belief in a Just World, Religious Worldviews, and Self-Esteem Within the Framework of Terror Management Theory: Mortality Salient and Nonmortality Salient Organizations

Time in the Mental Health Context: Neurotic Symptomatology, Defense Mechanisms and the Perception of Time Perspective Among Patients Diagnosed With Neurotic and Personality Disorders - A Clinical Study

Time Preferences, Mental Health and Treatment Utilization

Time Preference Shifts in Medical Decision-Making After Serious Illness

Supporting Health and Medical Decision Making: Findings and Insights from Fuzzy-Trace Theory

The double awareness of the wish to hasten death and the will to live: A secondary analysis of outlier patients from a mixed-methods study

Prognostic Information on Progression to Dementia: Quantification of the Impact on Quality of Life

A time to reflect: deviations from the balanced time perspective are associated with hypomentalization

"The greedy I that gives"-The paradox of egocentrism and altruism: Terror management and system justification perspectives on the interrelationship between mortality salience and charitable donations amid the COVID-19 pandemic