Abstract:The single-celled ciliate Stentor coeruleus demonstrates habituation to mechanical stimuli, showing that even single cells can manifest a basic form of learning. Although the ability of Stentor to habituate has been extensively documented, the mechanism of learning is currently not known. Here we take a bottom-up approach and investigate a simple biochemistry-based model based on prior electrophysiological measurements in Stentor along with general properties of receptor molecules. In this model, a mechanoreceptor senses the stimulus and leads to channel opening to change membrane potential, with a sufficient change in polarization triggering an action potential that drives contraction. Receptors that are activated can become tagged for inactivation, which may occur either via internalization, degradation, or some other mechanism. This activity-dependent inactivation provides a potential means for the cell to learn. Stochastic simulations of this model confirm that it is capable of showing habituation similar to what is seen in actual Stentor cells, including the lack of dishabituation and the apparently step-like response of individual cells during habituation. The model also can account for several observations that a previous two-state Markov model could not, namely, the dependence of habituation rate on stimulus magnitude, which had to be added onto the two state model but arises naturally in the receptor inactivation model; the rate of response recovery after cessation of stimulation; and the ability of high frequency stimulus sequences to drive faster habituation that results in a lower response probability. The model makes the prediction that application of high force stimuli that do not normally habituate should drive habituation to weaker stimuli due to decrease in the receptor number, which serves as an internal hidden variable. We confirm this prediction using two new sets of experiments involving alternation of weak and strong stimuli. The model is unable to account for the phenomenon of rate sensitivity, in which habituation caused by higher frequency stimuli is more easily reversed leading to a frequency dependence of response recovery. Such rate sensitivity has not been reported in Stentor. Here we carried out a new set of experiments which are consistent with the model's prediction of the lack of rate sensitivity. This work demonstrates how a simple model can suggest new ways to probe single-cell learning at an experimental level. Finally, we interpret the model in terms of a kernel estimator that the cell may use to guide its decisions about how to response to new stimuli as they arise based on information, or the lack thereof, from past stimuli.

Cellular cognition: How single cells learn using non-neural networks

Biochemically plausible models of habituation for single-cell learning

A receptor-inactivation model for single-celled habituation in Stentor coeruleus

Modeling somatic computation with non-neural bioelectric networks

Non-Associative Learning Representation in the Nervous System of the Nematode Caenorhabditis elegans

Interlinked switch circuits of biological intelligence

Habit learning supported by efficiently controlled network dynamics in naive macaque monkeys

Synthetic associative learning in engineered multicellular consortia

A computational model of behavioral adaptation to solve the credit assignment problem

Non-associative learning in intra-cellular signaling networks

A minimal model of cognition based on oscillatory and current-based reinforcement processes

Computation with Sequences of Assemblies in a Model of the Brain

Computation with Sequences in a Model of the Brain

Matter & Mind Matter

Cell motility: Bioelectrical control of behavior without neurons

An operating principle of the cerebral cortex, and a cellular mechanism for attentional trial-and-error pattern learning and useful classification extraction

Perovskite Quantum Organismoids

Searching for collective behavior in a small brain

A Minimal Model of Cognition Based on Oscillatory and Reinforcement Processes.

Multicellular artificial neural network-type architectures demonstrate computational problem solving

Biomimetic model of corticostriatal micro-assemblies discovers new neural code