Abstract:A major open problem in proof complexity is to demonstrate that random 3-CNFs with a linear number of clauses require super-polynomial size refutations in bounded-depth Frege systems. We take the first step towards addressing this question by establishing a super-linear lower bound: for every $k$, there exists $\epsilon_k > 0$ such that any depth-$k$ Frege refutation of a random $n$-variable 3-CNF with $\Theta(n)$ clauses has $\Omega(n^{1 + \epsilon_k})$ steps w.h.p. Our proof involves a novel adaptation of the deterministic restriction technique introduced by Chaudhuri and Radhakrishnan (STOC'96). For a given formula, this technique provides a method to fix a small number of variables in a bottom-up manner, ensuring that every surviving gate has small fan-in. Consequently, the resulting formula depends on a limited number of variables and can be simplified to a constant by a small variable assignment. Adapting this approach to proof complexity requires addressing the usual challenges associated with maintaining the hardness of a given instance. To this end, we introduce the following generalizations of standard proof complexity tools: - Weak expanders: These bipartite graphs relax the classical notion of expansion by only requiring that small sets have a non-empty boundary, while intermediate-sized sets have a large boundary. This property is sufficient to preserve hardness (e.g., for resolution width) and is easier to maintain as we remove vertices from the graph. - Formula assignments: To simplify a Frege proof, we consider a generalization of partial restrictions that assign values to formulas instead of just variables. We treat these assignments as new axioms added to our formula, as they generally cannot be expressed as variable substitutions.

Extremal Binary PFAs with Small Number of States

DFAs and PFAs with Long Shortest Synchronizing Word Length

Lower Bounds for Synchronizing Word Lengths in Partial Automata

Probabilistic automatic complexity of finite strings

An FPRAS for Model Counting for Non-Deterministic Read-Once Branching Programs

#CFG and #DNNF admit FPRAS

Decision Questions for Probabilistic Automata on Small Alphabets

Towards P$\ne$NP from Extended Frege lower bounds

Polynomially ambiguous probabilistic automata on restricted languages

A quadratic upper bound on the reset thresholds of synchronizing automata containing a transitive permutation group

State Complexity of Binary Coded Regular Languages

Bounded-Depth Frege Lower Bounds for Random 3-CNFs via Deterministic Restrictions

Smoothed Analysis of Trie Height by Star-like PFAs

A faster FPRAS for #NFA

Pushing the Limit of PFA: Enhanced Persistent Fault Analysis on Block Ciphers

A Robust Measure on FDFAs Following Duo-Normalized Acceptance

The Fibonacci Sequence and Schreier-Zeckendorf Sets

The Complexity of Finding Reset Words in Finite Automata

Extremal combinatorics, iterated pigeonhole arguments, and generalizations of PPP

Gaps, Ambiguity, and Establishing Complexity-Class Containments via Iterative Constant-Setting

The NFA Acceptance Hypothesis: Non-Combinatorial and Dynamic Lower Bounds