Modeling the Role of Weather and Pilgrimage Variables on Dengue Fever Incidence in Saudi Arabia

Kholood K. Altassan,Cory W. Morin,Jeremy J. Hess
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/pathogens13030214
IF: 3.7
2024-02-29
Pathogens
Abstract:The first case of dengue fever (DF) in Saudi Arabia appeared in 1993 but by 2022, DF incidence was 11 per 100,000 people. Climatologic and population factors, such as the annual Hajj, likely contribute to DF's epidemiology in Saudi Arabia. In this study, we assess the impact of these variables on the DF burden of disease in Saudi Arabia and we attempt to create robust DF predictive models. Using 10 years of DF, weather, and pilgrimage data, we conducted a bivariate analysis investigating the role of weather and pilgrimage variables on DF incidence. We also compared the abilities of three different predictive models. Amongst weather variables, temperature and humidity had the strongest associations with DF incidence, while rainfall showed little to no significant relationship. Pilgrimage variables did not have strong associations with DF incidence. The random forest model had the highest predictive ability (R2 = 0.62) when previous DF data were withheld, and the ARIMA model was the best (R2 = 0.78) when previous DF data were incorporated. We found that a nonlinear machine-learning model incorporating temperature and humidity variables had the best prediction accuracy for DF, regardless of the availability of previous DF data. This finding can inform DF early warning systems and preparedness in Saudi Arabia.
microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the impact of weather variables and pilgrimage activities on the incidence of dengue fever in Saudi Arabia, and try to create a robust dengue fever prediction model. Specifically, researchers hope to explore how these factors affect the dengue fever burden in Saudi Arabia by analyzing 10 - year data on dengue fever, weather, and pilgrimage, and determine the best statistical modeling method to predict the incidence of dengue fever. In addition, the study also aims to use this information to develop a model that can predict the incidence of dengue fever to assist in the development of early warning systems and preventive measures. ### Main research objectives: 1. **Evaluate the impact of weather variables and pilgrimage activities on the incidence of dengue fever**: Through 10 - year data, researchers analyzed the relationships between factors such as temperature, humidity, rainfall, and the number of pilgrims and the incidence of dengue fever. 2. **Determine the best statistical modeling method**: Three different prediction models (Poisson regression, ARIMA model, and random forest model) were compared to determine which model performs best in predicting the incidence of dengue fever. 3. **Develop a prediction model**: Using the above - analysis results, create a model that can effectively predict the incidence of dengue fever to facilitate the implementation of early warning and intervention measures. ### Research background: - **The prevalence of dengue fever in Saudi Arabia**: Since the first dengue fever case emerged in 1993, the incidence of dengue fever in Saudi Arabia has gradually increased, reaching 11 cases per 100,000 people in 2022. - **The influence of climate and population factors**: Climate factors (such as temperature, humidity, and rainfall) and population movement (such as the annual pilgrimage activities) may play an important role in the spread of dengue fever. - **The deficiencies of existing research**: Although there are many studies on the impact of weather and climate on dengue fever worldwide, there are relatively few related studies in Saudi Arabia, this specific region. ### Research methods: - **Data collection**: From 2009 to 2018, dengue fever cases, meteorological data, and pilgrimage data in Jeddah, Mecca, and Jizan were collected. - **Data analysis**: RStudio was used for data analysis, and Pearson correlation coefficients and bivariate analysis were used to select variables related to the number of dengue fever cases. - **Model comparison**: The prediction capabilities of Poisson regression, ARIMA model, and random forest model were compared, and the performance of different models under different conditions was evaluated. ### Main findings: - **The impact of weather variables**: Temperature and humidity have a significant association with the incidence of dengue fever, while the impact of rainfall is relatively small. - **The impact of pilgrimage activities**: The impact of pilgrimage activities on the incidence of dengue fever is not significant. - **Model performance**: The random forest model performs best (R² = 0.62) without the dengue fever data of the previous week, while the ARIMA model performs best (R² = 0.78) when including the dengue fever data of the previous week. ### Conclusion: This study successfully developed a model that can effectively predict the incidence of dengue fever by analyzing the impact of weather and pilgrimage activities on the incidence of dengue fever. This will help the public health department in Saudi Arabia to develop more effective prevention and control measures and reduce future dengue fever infections.