Abstract:Across both the developing and developed worlds, community engagement has become a key strategy for natural resource management. However, a growing number of studies report that community-based approaches are experiencing formidable challenges, with limited outcomes in terms of livelihoods, decentralization and sustainability. Yet, policies continue to focus attention unduly on “community participation”, ignoring the ways in which the “community” is itself embedded in a wider social system. Recent studies have shown that local communities are more complex than previously assumed, with local community actions being heavily shaped by wider social and environmental contexts. Yet, scholarly research tends to focus on reporting such cross-scalar dynamics, with little explanation of how and why they occur. This paper advances a framework to understand how local communities interact with the wider world, through what we term “delocalization of communities” in natural resource management. Using Bourdieu’s theory of social field, we present an approach to analyze various trajectories of delocalization involving the exchange of, and struggle for, a variety of resources valued in specific fields of natural resource governance.We extend the work of several researchers who have been critical of the conventional view of the community, and argue that a new model of delocalized “community” needs to be envisaged, one that emphasizes the interactions among actors within and between spatial scales and levels of political organization. While such a cross-scalar view is not novel, we deepen social field approach to assess how cross-scalar processes unfold in the course of “delocalization” of communities in the context of rapid social and environmental change. We draw on evidence from five different case studies from three continents that demonstrate specific aspects of the delocalization phenomenon.The cases selected are from Australia, Indonesia, Mexico, Nepal, and Papua New Guinea. We demonstrate through these cases that increasingly diverse interests in natural resources such as forests have served to delocalize communities beyond “local” domains. We conclude that local community is not a localized entity, and there are multiple cross-scale networks which need to be recognized, as these have profound implications in community-based natural resource management. In such situations, open and exploratory approaches - moving away from blueprint interventions - are required to facilitate context-specific fields and spheres of local democracy, nurturing diverse, flexible, and networked models of community participation, along with the recognition of political and economic influence coming from the wider domain.

Relational place-based solutions for environmental policy misalignments

Embodying relationality through immersive sustainability solutions with Indigenous communities in the Ecuadorian Amazon

Centering relationships to place for more meaningful research and engagement

Placing diverse knowledge systems at the core of transformative climate research

The Resilience of Indigenous Peoples to Environmental Change

Integrating social and ecological considerations in floodplain relocation and restoration programs

Reconciliation and Relationality in Water Research and Management in Canada: Implementing Indigenous Ontologies, Epistemologies, and Methodologies

Disrupting and diversifying the values, voices and governance principles that shape biodiversity science and management

Rethinking Sustainable Development Using Deep Ecology and Adaptive Governance of Social-Ecological Systems: Implications for Protected Areas Management

Indigenous Feminisms: Disturbing Colonialism in Environmental Science Partnerships

Policy collision: a framework to identify where polycentric, multi-objective sustainability solutions are needed

Environmental Concern: Examining the Role of Place Meaning and Place Attachment

Solving the Crisis in Ocean Governance: Place-Based Management of Marine Ecosystems

Delocalizing Communities: Changing Forms of Community Engagement in Natural Resources Governance

Untapped capacity for resilience in environmental law

The relational shift in urban ecology: From place and structures to multiple modes of coproduction for positive urban futures

Transforming cross-cultural water research through trust, participation and place

Place-Based Bias in Environmental Scholarship Derived from Social–Ecological Landscapes of Fear

Studying Across: Anthropology, Conflict Transformation and Cultural Violence in Environmental Conflict

Land Use Policy Frameworks in Canada and Aotearoa New Zealand: Examining the Opportunities and Barriers of Indigenous-Led Conservation and Protected Areas

Promoting community health and climate justice co-benefits: insights from a rural and remote island climate planning process