Babesiosis: Analysis of the Evidence for Infections in the United Kingdom
Michael Cook,Basant Puri
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/ijgm.s485759
IF: 2.145
2024-10-15
International Journal of General Medicine
Abstract:Michael J Cook, 1 Basant K Puri 2– 4 1 Vis À Vis Symposiums, Bury St Edmunds, UK; 2 CAR, Cambridge, UK; 3 Department of Psychology, Neapolis University, Pafos, 8042, Cyprus; 4 Faculty of Health and Wellbeing, University of Winchester, Winchester, UK Correspondence: Michael J Cook, Email Human babesiosis is caused when erythrocytes are invaded by Babesia . Infection can occur from the bite of an infected tick, blood transfusion or congenitally. Issues related to the infecting species, symptomology and testing technology are discussed and the implications of accurate incidence and prevalence of the disease discussed. Human babesiosis is considered to be relatively rare in the UK. With a considerable number of non-specific symptoms and diagnostic testing limitations, it is probable that true positives are being missed. Based on co-infection data for Borrelia and Babesia from Rhode Island and Connecticut, and on Borrelia seropositivity data from northeastern France, the prevalence of babesiosis in those aged under 35 years, 35 to 44 years, 45 to 54 years and 55 years and over would be expected to be 0.6%, 1.8%, 2.8% and 3.5%, respectively. Based on the prevalence of infections in ticks and canines and a disease model previously published, it is estimated that the UK incidence of human babesiosis is likely to be approximately 18,500 cases per year. Keywords: Babesia , Babesia venatorum , lyme disease, coinfection, blood transfusion, serology testing The Babesia parasite is named after the Romanian physician and scientist Victor Babeş who, in his 1888 paper entitled "Sur l'hémoglobinurie bactérienne du bœuf", described the micro-organism in erythrocytes of cattle affected by febrile haemoglobinuria. 1 The bovine disease has various names including red water fever and has caused serious economic loss in many parts of the world. The first identification of Babesia ( Piroplasma divergens ) in the UK was in 1911 by M'Fadyean and Stockman in cattle, 2 and the first case of human babesiosis in the UK was reported in Scotland in 1979. 3 There are more than 100 Babesia species known to infect mammals and birds, 4 with the Ixodes ricinus tick being the major carrier in Europe. A study by Bajer and Dwużnik-Szarek summarised information from 129 papers published over a 20-year period up to 2021 in which Babesia species were identified in ticks and GenBank molecular data. 5 Data for common European/UK Ixodes tick species demonstrated a prevalence of infection ranging from 0.5% in Denmark to 51% in Austria. There were seven species identified and other unnamed species that cause human babesiosis, with B. divergens, B. microti and B. venatorum the most common. Young et al listed over 1300 papers relevant to human babesiosis, including 11 with UK-specific data. 6 The most recent UK investigations identified a Babesia species (Clade X) in Scotland. 7 With more than 10 species and subspecies present in the UK and no published data on testing-accuracy for these, nor any surveillance data on human infections, the risk of infection and current incidence in the UK is unknown. Babesia infections cause a wide range of symptoms including fatigue, headaches, chills, muscle and joint pains. These can vary from very mild to severe and can persist and be fatal. Whilst severe Babesia disease in the past has been associated with splenectomised patients, a recent paper highlights the occurrence of a "polymorphic persistent syndrome" including neurological and cognitive disorders with a positive serology and PCR for Babesia divergens in an immunocompetent, un-splenectomised patient. 8 The symptoms are very similar to those of Lyme disease (LD). 9 Differences between LD and Babesia symptoms have been described with "air hunger", chest pains, sweats and hip pains described. 10 Swanson et al, in a paper titled "Coinfections Acquired from Ixodes Ticks" give extensive data and references of humans multiply infected by pathogens from tick bites. 11 There are many reports of patients diagnosed with Lyme disease and simultaneously infected with Babesia parasites. 12–15 Increased symptom severity when Borrelia and Babesia infections occur simultaneously has been documented. 16 Djokic et al demonstrated that B. microti subverts adaptive immunity and enhances Lyme disease severity 17 and the number of symptoms and duration of illness are greater when coinfected by Babesia and Borrelia . 18 In the US, where babesiosis is a not -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal