Abstract:Abstract Marine organisms are simultaneously exposed to anthropogenic stressors associated with ocean acidification and ocean warming, with expected interactive effects. Species from different trophic levels with dissimilar characteristics and evolutionary histories are likely to respond differently. Here, we perform a meta-analysis of controlled experiments including both ocean acidification and ocean warming factors to investigate single and interactive effects of these stressors on marine species. Contrary to expectations, we find that synergistic interactions are less common (16%) than additive (40%) and antagonistic (44%) interactions overall and their proportion decreases with increasing trophic level. Predators are the most tolerant trophic level to both individual and combined effects. For interactive effects, calcifying and non-calcifying species show similar patterns. We also identify climate region-specific patterns, with interactive effects ranging from synergistic in temperate regions to compensatory in subtropical regions, to positive in tropical regions. Our findings improve understanding of how ocean warming, and acidification affect marine trophic levels and highlight the need for deeper consideration of multiple stressors in conservation efforts.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of exploring the individual and interactive effects of ocean acidification (OA) and ocean warming (OW) on marine organisms at different trophic levels. Specifically, the study aims to systematically evaluate, through meta-analysis, how these two global change factors individually or jointly affect different marine trophic levels, including primary producers, herbivores, intermediate predators, and top predators. The study particularly focuses on the manifestation of these effects in different climatic regions (such as tropical, subtropical, and temperate) and whether these effects exhibit synergistic, additive, or antagonistic interactions. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **Differences in responses at different trophic levels**: Are there differences in the responses of marine organisms at different trophic levels to ocean acidification and ocean warming? 2. **Types of interactive effects**: Are the interactive effects of ocean acidification and ocean warming synergistic, additive, or antagonistic? 3. **Specific patterns in climatic regions**: Are there specific patterns in the interactive effects of ocean acidification and ocean warming in different climatic regions (such as tropical, subtropical, and temperate)? 4. **Responses of calcifying vs. non-calcifying species**: Are there differences in the responses of calcifying and non-calcifying species to ocean acidification and ocean warming? ### Research Background: Global climate change-induced ocean acidification and ocean warming have significant impacts on marine ecosystems. These changes affect not only primary producers but also intermediate consumers and top predators in the food web. However, most studies typically focus on the impact of a single stressor, neglecting the interactions between multiple stressors. Therefore, this study uses a meta-analysis approach, synthesizing data from 162 full-factorial experiments, to comprehensively assess the individual and interactive effects of ocean acidification and ocean warming on marine organisms at different trophic levels. ### Research Significance: By systematically evaluating the effects of ocean acidification and ocean warming on marine organisms at different trophic levels, this study helps to better understand the complex impacts of global climate change on marine ecosystems and provides a scientific basis for formulating effective conservation strategies. In particular, the results emphasize the importance of considering multiple stressors, which is crucial for the protection and management of marine ecosystems.

Responses of marine trophic levels to the combined effects of ocean acidification and warming

Interactive effects of multiple stressors in coastal ecosystems

Hidden impacts of ocean warming and acidification on biological responses of marine animals revealed through meta-analysis

Responses of Marine Primary Producers to Interactions Between Ocean Acidification, Solar Radiation, and Warming

Combining mesocosms with models reveals effects of global warming and ocean acidification on a temperate marine ecosystem

Ocean Acidification and Warming Will Lower Coral Reef Resilience

Effects of Ocean Acidification on Marine Photosynthetic Organisms under the Concurrent Influences of Warming, UV Radiation, and Deoxygenation

Key benthic species are affected by predicted warming in winter but show resistance to ocean acidification

Interactive Effects of Warming and Pollutants on Marine and Freshwater Invertebrates

Impacts of Multiple Stressors on a Benthic Foraminiferal Community: A Long-Term Experiment Assessing Response to Ocean Acidification, Hypoxia and Warming

Synergistic effects of ocean acidification and warming on coral host, Symbiodinium and nutrients exchange-based symbioses indicated by metatranscriptome

The synergistic negative effects of combined acidification and warming on the coral host and its symbiotic association with Symbiodiniaceae indicated by RNA-Seq differential expression analysis

The Impacts of Ocean Acidification, Warming and Their Interactive Effects on Coral Prokaryotic Symbionts

Hypoxia and acidification in ocean ecosystems: coupled dynamics and effects on marine life

Impacts of Ocean Acidification under Multiple Stressors on Typical Organisms and Ecological Processes

Temperature-dependent responses and trophic interaction strengths of a predatory marine gastropod and rock oyster under ocean warming

The Combined Effects of Ocean Acidification and Heavy Metals on Marine Organisms: A Meta-Analysis

A Regional View of the Response to Climate Change: A Meta-Analysis of European Benthic Organisms' Responses

Biological Responses of Two Marine Organisms of Ecological Relevance to On-Going Ocean Acidification and Global Warming

Additive Impacts of Ocean Acidification and Ambient Ultraviolet Radiation Threaten Calcifying Marine Primary Producers

Effects of Ocean Acidification on Marine Primary Producers and Related Ecological Processes Under Multiple Stressors