Abstract:Randomized trials typically estimate average relative treatment effects, but decisions on the benefit of a treatment are possibly better informed by more individualized predictions of the absolute treatment effect. In case of a binary outcome, these predictions of absolute individualized treatment effect require knowledge of the individual's risk without treatment and incorporation of a possibly differential treatment effect (i.e. varying with patient characteristics). In this paper we lay out the causal structure of individualized treatment effect in terms of potential outcomes and describe the required assumptions that underlie a causal interpretation of its prediction. Subsequently, we describe regression models and model estimation techniques that can be used to move from average to more individualized treatment effect predictions. We focus mainly on logistic regression-based methods that are both well-known and naturally provide the required probabilistic estimates. We incorporate key components from both causal inference and prediction research to arrive at individualized treatment effect predictions. While the separate components are well known, their successful amalgamation is very much an ongoing field of research. We cut the problem down to its essentials in the setting of a randomized trial, discuss the importance of a clear definition of the estimand of interest, provide insight into the required assumptions, and give guidance with respect to modeling and estimation options. Simulated data illustrates the potential of different modeling options across scenarios that vary both average treatment effect and treatment effect heterogeneity. Two applied examples illustrate individualized treatment effect prediction in randomized trial data.

A Single-Index Model With a Surface-Link for Optimizing Individualized Dose Rules

A high-dimensional single-index regression for interactions between treatment and covariates

Bayesian Index Models for Heterogeneous Treatment Effects on a Binary Outcome

Estimation of Optimal Individualized Treatment Rules Using a Covariate-Specific Treatment Effect Curve With High-Dimensional Covariates

Flexible Inference of Optimal Individualized Treatment Strategy in Covariate Adjusted Randomization with Multiple Covariates

A Single Index Model for Longitudinal Outcomes to Optimize Individual Treatment Decision Rules

FUSED KERNEL-SPLINE SMOOTHING FOR REPEATEDLY MEASURED OUTCOMES IN A GENERALIZED PARTIALLY LINEAR MODEL WITH FUNCTIONAL SINGLE INDEX

Estimating individualized treatment rules in longitudinal studies with covariate-driven observation times

Penalized Spline Estimation for Partially Linear Single-Index Models

Functional additive models for optimizing individualized treatment rules

Individualized treatment effect was predicted best by modeling baseline risk in interaction with treatment assignment

Measuring the individualization potential of treatment individualization rules: Application to rules built with a new parametric interaction model for parallel-group clinical trials

Optimal designs for dose–response models with linear effects of covariates

Penalized estimation for single-index varying-coefficient models with applications to integrative genomic analysis

A tutorial on individualized treatment effect prediction from randomized trials with a binary endpoint

Robust Optimal Design of Two-Armed Trials with Side Information

Estimating Individual Dose-Response Curves under Unobserved Confounders from Observational Data

Selection of the Optimal Personalized Treatment from Multiple Treatments with Right-censored Multivariate Outcome Measures

Identification of the Optimal Treatment Regimen in the Presence of Missing Covariates

Spline Estimation of Single-Index Models

Optimal Statistical Inference for Individualized Treatment Effects in High-dimensional Models