Exploring the Effects of Light and Dark on Crime in London

Ezgi Erturk,Peter Raynham,Jemima Unwin Teji

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijgi13060182

IF: 3.4

2024-05-30

ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information

Abstract:Safety from crime is a fundamental human need. In Maslow's hierarchy, safety is one of the foundational needs of well-being. The built environment should be safe to use at all times of the day and for all groups of people. After dark, the appearance of the outdoor environment changes dramatically, and this could impact the opportunities for crime. This study investigated the impact of daylight on the rates of different types of crime by comparing the crime rates during selected periods of daylight and darkness. The study used records of crime data from the Metropolitan Police Service. By studying crimes in the week on either side of the twice-yearly clock change, it is possible to compare periods that are dark in one week and light in the other at the same clock time. Where the time at which the crime took place was known, and using the GPS coordinates of the specific crime, the solar altitude was calculated and used to determine if it was light or dark at the time of the crime. A similar calculation was used to see if the crime would have been in the dark or light in the week on the other side of the clock change. The headline result is that there was 4.8% (OR 1.07) more crime in the dark periods than the light ones. However, this increase was not uniform across all crime types, and there were some further complications in some results due to potential changes in the behavior of some victims after dark. For the crimes of theft from a person and robbery of personal property, there was a significant increase during the dark period. The availability of light had an impact on the rate of certain crimes. Whilst this does not provide any information about the impact of street lighting on crime, it does provide some idea of by how much crime could be reduced if better lighting was provided.

geography, physical,remote sensing,computer science, information systems

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the question of whether lighting conditions in outdoor environments (daytime or nighttime) affect crime rates. Specifically, the study explores the impact of lighting conditions on different types of crime by comparing crime rates during periods of light and darkness within specific time frames. The researchers utilized crime data provided by the London Metropolitan Police and conducted a comparative analysis within a week before and after the clock adjustments in the spring and autumn seasons to minimize the influence of other variables, thereby more accurately assessing the specific impact of lighting conditions on criminal behavior.

The main objective of the study is to investigate whether there is a relationship between outdoor lighting conditions and the occurrence of crimes with known times. The study proposes four hypotheses:
1. There are seasonal differences in the impact of light and darkness on crime, with the expectation that changes in autumn will be greater than in spring because it gets dark earlier in autumn.
2. Crime rates vary within a 24-hour cycle.
3. If lighting affects crime, then crimes during nighttime/dark periods should differ from those during daytime/light periods.
4. Light and darkness have different effects on different types of crime, such as outdoor crimes like robbery and theft increasing after dark, while other types of crime may not follow this pattern.

To achieve this, the study employed precise solar elevation angle calculations and only used crime records with known occurrences within a 5-minute time window. This method allows for a more accurate assessment of the impact of changes in lighting conditions on crime rates.