Abstract:The enormous environmental impact of construction is becoming increasingly apparent and unacceptable to many structural engineers, whose designs typically account for the majority of a building's embodied carbon. It is timely, therefore, that consensus is forming around a methodology for calculating embodied carbon. This encourages the inclusion of all life cycle stages, from material production and construction, through use and eventual demolition, disposal and reuse. In practice, however, end-of-life processes are fraught with uncertainty and often ignored, despite the potentially large associated carbon fluxes. Further uncertainty exists when considering bio-based construction materials, which store carbon during use. There are no widely-accepted means of accounting for timing of these carbon fluxes, despite the long service life of most buildings. Could we consider whole-life carbon in a more holistic and climate-focused way?This article uses dynamic life cycle assessment to convert greenhouse gas emission histories to key climate impacts using a simple dynamic model. The implications for structural design decisions are explored by comparing concrete, steel and timber options for a typical medium-rise building structure. Concrete is found to have a higher impact than steel, with the climate response of both options dominated by the large initial emissions of material production and construction. Timber has the smallest impact, for this example, under a typical scenario with sustainable forest management and re-emission of sequestered carbon at end-of-life. The analysis takes a forward-looking approach to sequestration, with timing corresponding to the growth of replanted trees. An optimistic timber scenario, whereby future carbon-capture technology avoids most end-of-life emissions, demonstrates the possibility of structures with small long-term climate cooling effects. Conversely, in a hypothetical worst-case scenario where no replanting or subsequent sequestration occurs, the long-term warming effect of the timber structure is increased by the net emission of biogenic carbon.Although end-of-life processes are important in the long-term, particularly for timber, the analysis also highlights the importance of the initial emissions from material production and construction. These cause high rates of short-term temperature increase and prolonged accumulation of radiative heat for all the buildings, but the impacts are again lowest for timber.Most importantly, the investigation shows how dynamic life cycle assessment can be used to explore climate impacts in a comprehensive, graphical and unbiased way. As a simple extension to established methodologies for calculating embodied carbon, it is a powerful decision making tool in the climate emergency.

A systematic investigation into the methodological variables of embodied carbon assessment of buildings

Assessment of embodied carbon emissions for building construction in China: Comparative case studies using alternative methods

Factors That Influence the Quantification of the Embodied Carbon Emission of Prefabricated Buildings: A Systematic Review, Meta-Analysis and the Way Forward

The impact of life cycle assessment database selection on embodied carbon estimation of buildings

An Assessment Framework for Analyzing the Embodied Carbon Impacts of Residential Buildings in China

A Holistic Framework for Determining the Trade-off between Embodied and Operational Carbon Emissions of High-rise Residential Buildings

Material quantities and embodied carbon dioxide in structures

Factors influencing embodied carbon emissions of China's building sector: An analysis based on extended STIRPAT modeling

Scrutinising embodied carbon in buildings: The next performance gap made manifest

Embodied carbon benchmarks of single-family residential buildings in the United States

Embodied energy and carbon emissions of building materials in China

Embodied energy and embodied carbon of structural building materials: Worldwide progress and barriers through literature map analysis

Quantitative research on embodied carbon emissions in the design stage: a case study from an educational building in China

Measuring embodied carbon dioxide equivalent of buildings: A review and critique of current industry practice

Measuring Embodied Carbon of Buildings: A Review of Methodologies and Benchmarking Towards Net Zero

Embodied carbon emissions in buildings: explanations, interpretations, recommendations

Embodied carbon assessment using a dynamic climate model: Case-study comparison of a concrete, steel and timber building structure

A Building Life-Cycle Embodied Performance Index—The Relationship between Embodied Energy, Embodied Carbon and Environmental Impact

Investigating the impediments to carbon emission mitigation in prefabricated construction: a stakeholder perspective

Whole‐life embodied carbon in multistory buildings: Steel, concrete and timber structures

Characteristics of embodied carbon emissions for high-rise building construction: A statistical study on 403 residential buildings in China