An international perspective on the German Excellence Initiative
FENG Li-yin,ZHONG Zhou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-4519.2009.03.002
2009-01-01
Abstract:In every country in the world, politicians, scholars, university administrators and others are concerned with the quality of their nation’s universities. In this article, I look at the way in which one major world power, Germany, has reacted to the realisation that its universities are not regarded as excellent around the world, and that this judgement is supported by data on citations and other measures. The German government has reacted to this awareness by putting significant sums of money into a small number of universities to sharpen and deepen their excellence in research and scholarship. This approach imitates that taken in the United States and the United Kingdom. In these countries, which dominate university rankings, most research money goes into a small number of elite universities, which also attract the best-qualified students. But we need to realise that there is a difference between having a few top universities, and having a good university system. In the modern world, all nations need a growing supply of skilled, innovative professionals, to build their economies and to run public services. It would be wrong to prioritise competing with Harvard above having a large, effective higher education sector. Excellence, even on the world stage, is only one aspect of effective education.