Azole resistance screening in Aspergillus fumigatus sensu stricto using the azole-containing agar method (EUCAST E.Def 10.2): conidial suspension filtration and inoculum adjustment before inoculum preparation may not be needed

Julia Serrano-Lobo,Elena Reigadas,Patricia Muñoz,Pilar Escribano,Jesús Guinea,Waldo Sánchez-Yebra Romera,Juan Antonio Sánchez-Gómez,Inmaculada Guerrero Lozano,Rocío Tejero-García,Fernando Cobo Martínez,Laura Viñuela,Francisco Franco-Álvarez de Luna,Ana Lara Oya,Isabel Casanovas Moreno-Torres,María Pilar Bermúdez Ruiz,Ana Isabel Suárez Barrenechea,Carmen Castro Méndez,Maite Ruiz Pérez de Pipaón,Héctor Condado Condado,Rocío Cebollada Sánchez,Concepción López Gómez,Emilio David Valverde Romero,Henar Villar Pérez,Marta Arias Temprano,Alba Guiu Martínez,Teresa Peláez,Cristian Castello-Abietar,Carmen Collado Giner,Eva Alcoceba Cruixent,Carla Iglesias Escobar,Ana Patricia Martínez Lafuente,Ana Gual de Torrella,Leyre López-Soria,Olga Bello Jiménez,Miren Josebe Unzaga Barañano,Iris Sharon Pérez Ramos,Miren Nekane Azkue Albizu,Marina Fernández-Torres,Raúl Gilarranz Luengo,Isabel de Miguel Martínez,Ángeles Sampere Martínez,Silvia Rosa Campos Gutiérrez,María Pía Roiz Mesones,Julia Lozano Serra,Cristina Colmenarejo Serrano,Quilez Malo Casero,María Elena Rodríguez Zurita,Rosa Jiménez Barrena,Marta Fernández Esgueva,Oscar Fraile Santos,Beatriz Pascual Sánchez,Cristina Labayru Echeverría,Lisbeth Gonçalves De Freitas,Laura Milian Gay,Raquel Calleja Fernández,Alicia Barreales Fonseca,Almudena Silvia Tinajas Puertas,Irene López-Ramos,Moisés García Bravo,Juan Luis Muñoz Bellido,Noelia Arenal Andrés,Cristina Veintimilla Yánez,Susana Hernando Real,M. Rosario Ibáñez Pérez,Federico Miguel Becerra Aparicio,Jesús Martínez López,Pilar Soria,Carmen Aldea Mansilla,Belén Lorenzo Vidal,Irene Merino Velasco,Mercedes Martín Gil,María Antonia Miguel Gómez,Cristina López Mestanza,Jaime Martín Cornejo,María Luz Asensio Calle,Adrián Antuori Torres,Eva Cuchí Burgos,Ferran Sánchez-Reus,Cristina López-Querol,Jaume Juanola Para,Francesc Marco Reverté,Mateu Espasa,Josefina Ayats Ardite,Roberto Olmos,David Sanchez Ramos,María Teresa Martín Gómez,Montserrat Colomer Palau,Iván Prats Sánchez,Isabel Pujol Bajador,Antonio Casabella Pernas,Frederic Francesc Gómez Bertomeu,Sergio Pardo Granell,Ester Picó Plana,María Dolores Guerrero Torres,María Mar Olga Pérez Moreno,Eva del Corral Rodríguez,Miguel Fajardo Olivares,Carmen Pazos Pacheco,María Dolores Rodríguez-Mayo,Susana Méndez Lage,Javier Alba Domínguez,Yolanda Vila Fernández,y Susana Orol Maseda,Ana Cid Lama,Ana María Rodríguez Rey,María de los Ángeles Pallarés González,Raquel Carballo-Fernández,Rocío Trastoy Pena,Lucía Martínez-Lamas,Luis Miguel Soria Blanco,Ana Pérez-Ayala,Elia Gómez García de la Pedrosa,Isabel Sánchez-Romero,Sarela García-Masedo Fernández,Jesus Guinea,Pilar Escribano,Ana Gómez Núñez,José González Leiva,Laura Pérez Palomares,Asta Kastanauskaite Liaudansdanskyte,Natalia Díaz Rodríguez,Sarah Montero Pérez,Julia Serrano-Lobo,Elena Reigadas,Patricia Muñoz García de Paredes,Inmaculada Quiles Melero,Paloma García Clemente,María Teresa Durán-Valle,Ignacio Gadea,Marta Martín García,Nelly Zurita,Ainhoa Gutiérrez,María Soledad Cuétara,Paloma Merino Amador,Irene Díaz de la Torre,Mirian Fernández-Alonso,Irene Arco Montoro,Eugenio García-Figueres,Victoria Sánchez Hellín,María Isabel Gascón Ros,Salvador Raga Borja,Amparo Valentín Martín,Alba Ruiz Gaitán,Javier Colomina Rodríguez,Beatriz Olea,María de los Ángeles Clari,on behalf of the ASPEIN Study Group
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1128/jcm.00369-24
2024-06-01
Journal of Clinical Microbiology
Abstract:ABSTRACT Azole resistance screening in Aspergillus fumigatus sensu stricto can be routinely carried out by using azole-containing agar plates (E.Def 10.2 procedure); however, conidial suspension filtering and inoculum adjustment before inoculum preparation are time-consuming. We evaluated whether skipping the filtration and inoculum adjustment steps negatively influenced the performance of the E.Def 10.2 procedure. A. fumigatus sensu stricto isolates ( n = 98), previously classified as azole susceptible or azole resistant (E.Def 9.4 method), were studied. Azole-resistant isolates had either the wild-type cyp51A gene sequence ( n = 1) or the following cyp51A gene substitutions: TR 34 -L98H ( n = 41), G54R ( n = 5), TR 46 -Y121F-T289A ( n = 1), or G448S ( n = 1). In-house azole-containing agar plates were prepared according to the EUCAST E.Def 10.2 procedure. Conidial suspensions obtained by adding distilled water (Tween 20 0.1%) were either filtered and the inocula adjusted to 0.5 McFarland or left unfiltered and unadjusted. Agreements between the agar screening methods using inocula prepared by each procedure were high for itraconazole (99%), voriconazole (100%), and posaconazole (94.9%). Sensitivity and specificity (considering the susceptibility category as per the microdilution E.Def 9.4 method as the gold standard) of E.Def 10.2 were 100% to rule in or rule out resistance when unfiltered and unadjusted suspensions were used; the resistance phenotype of isolates harboring the TR 34 -L98H, G54R, or TR 46 -Y121F-T289A substitutions was correctly detected. Unfiltered and unadjusted conidial suspensions do not negatively influence the performance of the E.Def 10.2 method when screening for azole resistance in A. fumigatus sensu stricto . IMPORTANCE Azole resistance screening in Aspergillus fumigatus sensu stricto can be routinely carried out by using azole-containing plates (E.Def 10.2 procedure); however, conidial suspension filtering and inoculum adjustment before inoculation of plates are time-consuming. We, here, showed that unfiltered and unadjusted conidial suspensions do not negatively influence the performance of the E.Def 10.2 method when screening for azole resistance in A. fumigatus sensu stricto .
microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?