Multi-stakeholder Perspective on Responsible Artificial Intelligence and Acceptability in Education
A. J. Karran,P. Charland,J-T. Martineau,A. Ortiz de Guinea Lopez de Arana,AM. Lesage,S. Senecal,P-M. Leger
2024-02-23
Abstract:This study investigates the acceptability of different artificial
intelligence (AI) applications in education from a multi-stakeholder
perspective, including students, teachers, and parents. Acknowledging the
transformative potential of AI in education, it addresses concerns related to
data privacy, AI agency, transparency, explainability and the ethical
deployment of AI. Through a vignette methodology, participants were presented
with four scenarios where AI's agency, transparency, explainability, and
privacy were manipulated. After each scenario, participants completed a survey
that captured their perceptions of AI's global utility, individual usefulness,
justice, confidence, risk, and intention to use each scenario's AI if
available. The data collection comprising a final sample of 1198
multi-stakeholder participants was distributed through a partner institution
and social media campaigns and focused on individual responses to four AI use
cases. A mediation analysis of the data indicated that acceptance and trust in
AI varies significantly across stakeholder groups. We found that the key
mediators between high and low levels of AI's agency, transparency, and
explainability, as well as the intention to use the different educational AI,
included perceived global utility, justice, and confidence. The study
highlights that the acceptance of AI in education is a nuanced and multifaceted
issue that requires careful consideration of specific AI applications and their
characteristics, in addition to the diverse stakeholders' perceptions.
Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction,Artificial Intelligence