Abstract:The article examines the inter-relations between self-identity and organizational change in advanced capitalist societies characterized by deregulation of markets, privatization and globalizing economic relations. It compares two contrasting perspectives on selfhood: the reflexive self (Giddens, 1991) and the corroded self (Sennett, 1998). Giddens suggests that contemporary organizations, rather than eroding meaning, offer a greater degree of choice about self-identity, and enhance reflexivity and agency. Sennett suggests that new economic forms are corrosive of character and social relations. Using examples from predominantly British data, it is argued that both accounts offer relevant insights into the interplay between selfhood and organizations, but that each overstates their case. Giddens offers a persuasive account of the choice and voluntarism characterizing self-identity for at least a proportion of the population. His account of the ‘project of the self’, however, contributes to an ideology of the flexible, commodified self, and an overly inflated sense of the potential for individualized self-growth. Sennett over-emphasizes the extent of change in organization and employment relations, at least in the British case, but points to the damaging effects of an ideology of individualism, to which Giddens’ model of the self as project potentially contributes. The article argues that short-termism is not the most damaging element of contemporary organization practices. Instead increased instrumentalism on the part of employers results in the experience of increased responsibility without meaningful discretion and authority. The gap between employers’ promises to empower people at work and the experience of greater burdens and uncertain prospects has negative consequences for trust and morale. In conclusion, it is suggested that character is not necessarily undermined by such dynamics: encountering the limits of self-determination, reflexivity and individualism provides the material for critique of new economic forms, as evidenced by public concern with issues of care and mutual dependence.

Identity Under Construction: How Individuals Come to Define Themselves in Organizations

Exploring the Organizational Identity Construction Process of Employees: The Dynamic Negotiation between Individuals and Organizations

Who will Lead and Who will Follow? a Social Process of Leadership Identity Construction in Organizations

Social identity theory and the organization

Construction at Work: Multiple Identities Scaffold Professional Identity Development in Academia

How to Expand and Fill the Self in Organizations: The Role of Interpersonal Processes in the Employee Organizational Identity Construction

Identity Construction: New Issues, New Directions

Self-Consciousness as a Construction All the Way Down

Individual and Collective Identity Construction in a Niké Related Brand Community

Implications of Individualist Bias in Social Identity Theory for Cross-Cultural Organizational Psychology

The social grounds of personal self: Interactions that build a sense of 'we' help clarify who 'I' am

Constructivist Self-Construal: A Cross-Cultural Comparison

The Past, Present, and Future of an Identity Theory*

Identity dynamics in international collaborations

Organizations, Self-Identities and the New Economy

Self-Organization and Social Organization: U.S. and Chinese Constructions

Human Nature in Self-Identity Construct: A Meta-ethnography Study

Identity Formation in Ritual Interaction

Becoming a leader: catalysts and barriers to leader identity construction

Identity and interaction: a sociocultural linguistic approach